DVC...Need quick advice! Are there any CONS?

DLBDS

Loves that Sweetened Condensed Milk
Joined
Jun 21, 2005
Messages
5,462
We just returned from WDW today and we did the DVC Open House while we were there. It all sounds really great but we wonder about what isn't being mentioned. Our DVC rep offered to match our points OR credit of $10 per point.

Also, a few questions...
1) Is there a minimum amount of points that can be added in the future. Like, can we add 20 points or is there a 50 pt. minimum?

2) What are the benefits of your home resort? (Other than being able to book 11 months out.)

3) Are there any hidden fess when adding or borrowing pts. from the next year's allotment? (We were told closing costs were only paid once.)

4) Can points roll over continuously from year to year or is it more like use-it-or-lose-it?

5) Finally, what exactly happens after 50 years?

These are all things we thought off after the open house. Our offer was to expire this past Thursday but the DVC rep said he would extend it until this Tues when we told him we wanted to discuss it some more and do a bit of research when we get home. I'm going to read the posts here but if someone will reply to these questions or offer advice......THANK YOU!
 
We just returned from WDW today and we did the DVC Open House while we were there. It all sounds really great but we wonder about what isn't being mentioned. Our DVC rep offered to match our points OR credit of $10 per point.

Also, a few questions...
1) Is there a minimum amount of points that can be added in the future. Like, can we add 20 points or is there a 50 pt. minimum?

The minimum purchase is 25 points at any DVC resort.

2) What are the benefits of your home resort? (Other than being able to book 11 months out.)

Your maintenance fees will be based on your Home Resort - otherwise the 11 month priority is the main advantage.

3) Are there any hidden fess when adding or borrowing pts. from the next year's allotment? (We were told closing costs were only paid once.)

There are no hidden fees. Closing costs are only related to the initial purchase. Otherwise, the only costs are the annual maintenance fees. While an assessment is possible, there has never been one at a DVC resort over the 16 years of existence.

4) Can points roll over continuously from year to year or is it more like use-it-or-lose-it?

Members are allowed to bank points into the next Use Year. Those points must be used or lost at the end of that time. Basically, it amounts to a 1-year extension for use. By using banking and borrowing, members can have up to 3 years of points available for a reservation during any given Use Year. Banking and Borrowing can be cancelled by DVC - although that has never happened.

5) Finally, what exactly happens after 50 years?

While no one knows the answer to that question - DVC recently voted (9/24/07) to extend the ground lease for OKW owners for an additional 15 years. Those owners have been given the option of extending their memberships for 15 years for $15 per point. At this time no announcement has been made regarding similar extensions for other DVC resorts. Currently VB, HH, BWV, VWL and BCV all expire on January 31, 2042. SSR expires on January 31, 2054 and AKV and OKW expire on January 31, 2057. (OKW contracts purchased thru DVC directly expire on that date - resale purchases expire then only if the current owner has extended their contract - otherwise it expires on January 31, 2042.)

These are all things we thought off after the open house. Our offer was to expire this past Thursday but the DVC rep said he would extend it until this Tues when we told him we wanted to discuss it some more and do a bit of research when we get home. I'm going to read the posts here but if someone will reply to these questions or offer advice......THANK YOU!

Good luck with your decision! :)
 
Is the $10/point for SSR? I just requested info by phone but it seems like we have a similar deal ($8 credit for AKLV) and the guide on the phone did give me any deadlines (though I presume this offer isn't good forever but he didn't say anything about when it expires). The "Dream" book they sent me had a sheet inside with the financing options. I know when I was talking to him about it he said that we could either get the per point credit or get an extra year of points. So same deal as you right?

If it is the same deal why should there be some deadline coming up so soon?

I just personally don't like it when I'm pressured with a deadline like that.:confused3
 
Is the $10/point for SSR? I just requested info by phone but it seems like we have a similar deal ($8 credit for AKLV) and the guide on the phone did give me any deadlines (though I presume this offer isn't good forever but he didn't say anything about when it expires). The "Dream" book they sent me had a sheet inside with the financing options. I know when I was talking to him about it he said that we could either get the per point credit or get an extra year of points. So same deal as you right?

If it is the same deal why should there be some deadline coming up so soon?

I just personally don't like it when I'm pressured with a deadline like that.:confused3

You got it. I agree about the sales tactics. DH wasn't and isn't falling for it. I'm more gullible. :rolleyes:
 

I've read here that the best advice is to purchase points at the resort you'll want to be staying at most. That's a problem. As you can see in my signature, I absolutely :love: the WL. SSR (which had the open house) was nice and all but it's a DTD resort and doesn't have the Disney theming that I prefer. AKL just doesn't do it for us either even though it's similar to the WL. The distance factor and the higher MF hold no appeal. My understanding is that these 2 resorts are the only ones available for sale. The WLV is sold out. Is this correct? I may need to wait for the CR announcement to be made before I commit to DVC. I prefer to be at a MK resort for MOST (but not all) of my stays. Any advice?
 
Selket, For AKV, you get $8 off... SSR you get $10 off. That being said, you should buy where you'd like to stay to get the home resort advantage of being able to book 11 months in advance.

Goldi
 
I've read here that the best advice is to purchase points at the resort you'll want to be staying at most. That's a problem. As you can see in my signature, I absolutely :love: the WL. SSR (which had the open house) was nice and all but it's a DTD resort and doesn't have the Disney theming that I prefer. AKL just doesn't do it for us either even though it's similar to the WL. The distance factor and the higher MF hold no appeal. My understanding is that these 2 resorts are the only ones available for sale. The WLV is sold out. Is this correct? I may need to wait for the CR announcement to be made before I commit to DVC. I prefer to be at a MK resort for MOST (but not all) of my stays. Any advice?

VWL is available both thru DVC directly and thru resale. While SSR and AKV are the oly resorts with any sales incentives (discounts) , all other DVC resorts are available for sale thru DVC.
 
VWL is available both thru DVC directly and thru resale. While SSR and AKV are the oly resorts with any sales incentives (discounts) , all other DVC resorts are available for sale thru DVC.

AS Doc said, all resorts should be available, but it depends on how many points DVC may have "one hand" for any given resort. They acquire points through defaults or ROFR. You may have to go on a wait list for a particular resort or use year. And there are no incentive discounts. Also, WVL contracts currently end in 2042, OKW is the only "original" resort to be extended to 2057, so far. If that is important to you, if they extend the lease for VWL like at OKW you will be paying additional fees to extend. At OKW it is $15 per point, we don't know if VWL will be extended, or what the price will be.
 
Some of the cons is maintenance fees which are a given. The other con is the more people that own the harder it becomes to get a room. The 11 month window may become more important than ever reinforcing buy where you want to stay. My fear is it will be like booking at CRT one day :lmao: . For us the other con is cost of flights.
 
I think at least you know which DVC resort your like and that is WL! I would just buy points there by resale or through Disney if they come up with points. In other words you would probably be most happy with points from there rather than points at SSR or AKLV.

I think you ought to ask your guide too why you have to decide by Tues. when someone else you talked to doesn't have that kind of deadline. That would just make me by off the resale market!

Good luck deciding - it is hard for us too!
 
We've just bought into DVC after our vacation in August this year. Like you we did the tour while we were there and we felt very similar to you with the decision about home resort - just didn't really want AKV or SSR....so we got home, did our research, checked out the resale markets - then phoned our guide to tell him we really wanted to buy VWL. No problem! They had points ready for exactly the use year we wanted, the only downside for us was that there were no $$ off points incentives. But we got exactly what we wanted - and we have no regrets at all.
 
It seems it it not uncommon for an incentive deadline to be given in person while it isn't necessarily mentioned by phone/mail contact. Why, I don't know. Perhaps because for most type of sales, especially timeshares, no matter how good the product is, after a visit with a salesperson the vast majority will either purchase with a short period of time, or not purchase at all. For many WDW guests, their first real exposure to DVC is their initial appointment with a guide. Once they leave for hime, many will then not be thinking about future WDW trips or DVC.
 
I've read here that the best advice is to purchase points at the resort you'll want to be staying at most. That's a problem. As you can see in my signature, I absolutely :love: the WL. SSR (which had the open house) was nice and all but it's a DTD resort and doesn't have the Disney theming that I prefer. AKL just doesn't do it for us either even though it's similar to the WL. The distance factor and the higher MF hold no appeal. My understanding is that these 2 resorts are the only ones available for sale. The WLV is sold out. Is this correct? I may need to wait for the CR announcement to be made before I commit to DVC. I prefer to be at a MK resort for MOST (but not all) of my stays. Any advice?

Have you tried looking into resale? I bought my 150 points VWL back in July and paid $80/pt. While you might run into a situation in which the seller has already used their 2007 points, and the longer period to close, it's still (I believe) cheaper than buying directly from Disney if you'd like to purchase their sold out resorts like VWL.
 
This is a great thread! We are also in the initial research process for DVC. You all have been a great help!
 
We just returned from WDW today and we did the DVC Open House while we were there. It all sounds really great but we wonder about what isn't being mentioned. Our DVC rep offered to match our points OR credit of $10 per point.!

We are brand spanking new DVC owners at AKV so are still very green, but I would like to take a shot at answering some of your questions. Hopefully, some of the more seasoned DVCers will correct any points I may not be 100% accurate on. Also, most of what I am saying is specifically referring to purchasing a new contract through DVC and not resales through third parties (though ultimately, once your purchase is complete, the same DVC rules and restictions apply to you as a member).

Call it semantics, but this is how I look at it. Currently, Saratoga Springs (SSR) and Animal Kingdom Villas (AKV) are the DVC resorts with new, unsold inventory, so those are the resorts that are ‘actively’ available and being sold. However, purchasers can always request through DVC, to buy an interest in one of the ‘sold out’ resorts, you just may need to be a little more firm with your request since the DVC Sales Guides will not actively promote the sold out resorts and instead push the NEW resorts that have unsold inventory.

When you request to purchase at one of the older, sold out resorts through DVC, you usually have to go on a Wait List until such time that a contract at your preferred resort becomes available. Normally, this occurs when an existing DVC owner sells their ownership in that resort and Disney purchases it back, at which time Disney offers it to persons on the wait list for that resort. There could be any number of people ahead of you on the wait list, making it unknown how long you may need to wait before getting your chance to buy at that resort. It could be available right away, or you could wait months.

Bear in mind, that you get fewer years when purchasing a contract for one of these older 'sold out' DVC resorts, including when you purchase the contract through a private resale... you only get the number of years remaining in the original owners contract. I believe contracts for most of the other DVC resorts will expire on 2042, while SSR goes to 2054 and AKV 2057. So you get fewer years when you choose to waitlist and purchase at one of the ‘sold out’ resorts, though I assume the price will reflect this. Also, there has recently been an extension for the Old Key West Resort for 15 more years, but you have to purchase the extension, you do not just get it for free. But more importantly, what this shows is anything could happen with the other resorts also.

As of 2 weekends ago when I spoke with OUR guide, there were two options available to us with respect to purchasing at SSR or AKV, and while he emphasized there was no specific deadline at the time for these offers, incentives often change with little to no advance notice;

Option 1: Minimum purchase required is 160 points. NO price break on cost per point, but they will MATCH however many points you buy, with Developer Points. Example, buy 235 pts., you get 235 Developer Points in addition. Developer points are a ONE time freebee and must be used within 12 months of your contract (purchase) date. Any unused Dev. Pts. after 12 months simply expire and are forfeited. Reservations utilizing Dev. Pts. must be booked within 7 months or less of the date you wish to stay (according to one of the documents in the contract, Disney Cruise Line is exempt from this 7 month restriction). There are a few other particulars as well.

Option 2: Minimum required purchase of 225 points at SSR or AKV and get flat 160 Developer Points PLUS $10 off/pt for SSR or $8 off/pt for AKV purchase. So in this case you get BOTH the cost per point discount PLUS the Developer points instead of only one or the other. As far as I know there is no $10/pt incentive for AKV so make sure you understand whether that is for SSR only, but these offers change all the time.

Some other ‘little things’ that aren’t necessarily explicitly mentioned during the sales pitch.
- While you can actually CALL to book a DVC vacation as soon as you receive the contract/paper work and your temporary DVC Member card, you cannot actually book a date for your visit until on or after a certain date known as your ‘Estimated Date Unit is Available for Occupancy’. For example, ours is ‘Jan. 29, 2008'. So even though we PURCHASED on Oct. 22, 2007, we can call TODAY to book a vacation on DVC points, but we cannot book the vacation for dates before Jan. 29, 2008. For people still buying in right now and getting 07 UY points, this can be an important point because that only leaves a 4 month window for you to use your 07 UY points, unless you bank them to your 08 UY.
- You cannot book AND travel to resorts within The Disney Collection (basically Disney resorts that are non-DVC), Concierge Collection (basically non Disney resorts around the world), and Adventurer Collection (more non-WDW/DL resorts around the world) within the last 60 days of your UY. Example, if your UY ends in 59 days, you cannot on a whim decide to call and book a stay at any of these resorts using your DVC points for the remaining days in your current UY because you are BOTH calling less than 60 days from the end of your UY, AND you want to stay during dates that fall within the last 60 days of your UY. You CAN book reservations in these places for dates that are within the last 60 days of your UY as long as the date you CALL to make the reservation is before 60 days from the end of your UY.
- Annual dues are almost guaranteed (my words, not Disney’s) to increase year to year (they have historically anyway, with a few minor exceptions), but this isn’t really any different than most Time Shares.
- Starting Jan. 1, 2008, you must decide whether or not to Bank any current UY points by the end of the 8th month of your UY. You cannot bank any current UY points once you are in months 9, 10, 11, or 12 of your UY. Thus if you are not careful to plan ahead a little, once you pass that 8 month deadline for banking your points, you better use them by the end of the current UY or they are forfeited.
- While you can use DVC points to stay at WDW Moderate Resorts (Caribbean Beach Resort, Coronado, Port Orleans, Fort Wilderness Campground) if you so choose, you cannot use DVC points to stay at Disney VALUE Resorts if for any reason you desired to do so.
- You cannot use DVC points to stay in the NON-DVC accomodations of a Disney resort that has a DVC affiliation. Example, if you are DYING to stay at the Beach Club Resort but there are NO DVC accomodations available for the date you need, you cannot use your DVC points to make a reservation in the standard Beach Club Resort accomodations as if you were making a reservation for a qualifying non-DVC resort.

Make sure you clearly understand all the different Cancellation particulars as well, as this is one area where points can easily be lost if you are not paying attention.



1) Is there a minimum amount of points that can be added in the future. Like, can we add 20 points or is there a 50 pt. minimum?

There is currently a minimum purchase of 25 points for cash (pay in full) purchases, and 50 points for financed purchases.


3) Are there any hidden fess when adding or borrowing pts. from the next year's allotment? (We were told closing costs were only paid once.)

There are none specifically related to Banking/Borrowing that I am aware of, however, there are some lesser known 'fees' you might have to pay with DVC point usage. There is an 'Administrative fee’ ($95 I believe starting Jan 1, 2008) associated with using your points to book a stay at all non DVC specific resorts/locations, including Disney resorts at WDW that are non-DVC resorts, as well as Disney Cruise Line.


4) Can points roll over continuously from year to year or is it more like use-it-or-lose-it?

As others have stated, no, vacation points for a given Use Year (UY) can only be banked once, and they cannot be returned to their original UY after they have been banked if you change your mind. Banking points to the next UY is final. Example, your 2008 pts. can be banked to you 2009 UY. Any unused 08 points at the end of your 2009 UY will expire and be forfeited.
Borrowing points is similar in that they cannot be returned to their original UY if you end up changing your mind or canceling the reservation you borrowed the points for. You can still use the Borrowed points for another reservation during the UY you’ve borrowed them into, but any Borrowed points expire and are lost if not used by the end of the UY in which they are borrowed into.

Sorry so long winded, but hopefully this will not only answer some of your questions, but others who are on the fence as well.
 
The main con I've run into is it's difficult to find last minute reservations. I travel on business frequently and sometimes want to add a night with points, but with less than a month notice. I wanted to find a room for the night of 10/14 about 3 weeks before and no WDW DVC had availability for any size room. I ended up booking POFQ for 18 points. Another con is next year that non-DVC reservation will have a $95 booking fee. So a non-DVC resort for 1 night will make no sense (I could have got an AP rate for $124 plus tax).
 
Also, there has recently been an extension for the Beach Club Villas for 15 more years, but you have to purchase the extension, you do not just get it for free. But more importantly, what this shows is anything could happen with the other resorts also.

Good post :thumbsup2 but I think you meant Old Key West? At the moment OKW is the only resort where an extension has been offered.
 
Good post :thumbsup2 but I think you meant Old Key West? At the moment OKW is the only resort where an extension has been offered.

D'OH! Yes, I meant to say Old Key West, thank you Moira. I have BCV on the brain right now..., haven't even received our 'permanent' DVC member cards yet for our AKV purchase and I'm already crunching numbers to see when we could potentially do a BCV Add on. Thanks again.
 
Wow! There's a lot to think about. Thanks for all the info. Now, if I could just convince my DH. I trust him implicitly when it comes to financial matters so if he says 'not now' then we'll have to wait. We're not planing to return to WDW until Jan/Feb '09 so if we need to wait a bit that's ok with me. Does anyone here in DVC mostly use it at WDW?
 
Does anyone here in DVC mostly use it at WDW?

Did you mean as opposed to non-DVC things like the cruise, WDW hotels, etc?

A previous post on this thread said that there would be a fee starting next year for about $95 a pop anytime you used points for anything other than a DVC stay (like for the DCL cruise, etc). Is that true? (not like I'm thinking you're lying but I wanted to make sure I'm understanding this!)
 





New Posts







DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom