I bet dizneeluvr wondered where I was and hadn't responded. I've been busy for a few days and missed this thread until now.
Big Cedar is FANTASTIC!!! Yes, the capital letters were a yell, sorry. I think it is a wonderful option in the DVC collection. We stayed in a one bdrm cabin (1998) and a two bdrm cabin (1999) on DVC points and loved both times. I have no info on the lodges but they must be great also. I had no problem with using points, that's why I have them for vacations and it saves my cash. The two bdrm cabin was 141 points for three nights with a rack rate, back then, of $1200 plus tax. Close to the $10 per point some use as a guide. My only complaint on the points for the Concierge Collection list is they give you a point for the cabin (two adults for the one bdrm) and charge you extra points for additional kids over a certain age (can't remember the age right now). You have to watch that.
We now own points at Big Cedar Wilderness Club (Bluegreen Vacation Club) and have stayed once in our two bdrm cabin. Can't be beat. The Lodge and the Club have the same architecture and cabin floor plan and the Club shares the Lodges facilities. Not sure if the Lodge still uses our lazy river.
To answer your question, if the Wilderness Club was not part of our Vacation Clubs we would not hessitate to use our DVC points at Big Cedar Lodge.