Driving vs. Flying

cjemscott

Mouseketeer
Joined
Apr 5, 2008
Messages
177
My DH and I can not decide if we should drive or fly for our next trip...

I just priced plane tix for next March on Travelocity and for the 4 of us it was just under $800. We have a Ford Explorer and would be paying for 2-3 nights total in a hotel then gas/food expenses. Cost is a huge factor in the decision plus the downside to me with flying is that I'm limited on what I can pack and take...But I've only ever flown to WDW, so I don't know if travel with a car is easier than disney transportation within the parks/resorts.

Any suggestions/opinions to help us with our decision?? Thanks!
 
What part of Indiana are you from? I'm in Evansville. We were having the hardest time trying to decide that ourselves. I think that we are going to drive. It's about a 13 hour trip or so. I really wanted to fly, but the thought of lugging carseats and strollers and 2 kids thru the airport just doesn't appeal to me.
 
I meant to put that in my original post - duh! I'm from Muncie, IN - so about 19 hours away...
 

I have driven and flown as well, flying is so much easier and I always rent a car because I like to get to the parks faster than taking DWT. I always go to Ebay and buy a AAA Diamond parking pass so I get VIP parking and can park close to the entrance for easier access. My DD is 10 now so I don't have to worry about all the accessories that come with a little one but I still like the fact that my vehicle is right up front.
 
Fly. By then who knows what the price of gas will be and if you can lock in airline tickets now at a reasonable price, you should do so!!
 
We've driven it twice and we decided to fly this time. Gas is so high and we would have to stay overnight on the way down and on the way back. We live in the same general area as you, and we got our plane tickets on Southwest for about $850 (3 of us + 1 lap baby). We figured with gas, overnight hotels and food while traveling, we're not spending much more by flying. We'll have a 17 month old at the time, and I just did not want her to be cooped up for 38 hours in a car total travel time. 4 hours total in a roomy plane sounds much nicer. :goodvibes

So I vote for FLY! :thumbsup2
 
I vote for flying...try www.kayak.com to check the prices for flights. We drove from Phila. a few years ago and I prefer to fly. The time and cost is worth it:) Also, DWT is awesome!
 
Definately fly. You will enjoy it so much more! We are from Southern Indiana across the bridge from Louisville. Flying is not bad at all...just gate check everything except the kids and enjoy yourselves!!:rotfl2:
 
drive....but I hate to fly so that's a no brainer! However, realistically it would probably be cheaper to fly. And if your explorer is like mine, you'd end up having to fly at some point anyway. :lmao:
 
We just got back from WDW and drove both ways at about 13 hours each way. I would do it again at the cost savings. It cost us about $300 to drive and it would have cost us 3x that much to fly. I did all the driving and we did it non stop. I did get very tired at the last 2 hours or so but it was manageable.
 
My mother just called me to tell me that my sister found airfare for not much different than the price of gas from here to Florida—thought I might be interested. I had to explain to her that price only was part of the reason we drive. I also find it extremely hard to believe. I find cheaper rates on everything than my sister and I’ve found airfare for 5 to be way more than the price of gas and we drive the say kind of vehicle—and let’s not forget the cost of checking luggage. That alone, round trip, is 80% of the cost of gas—even with the higher rates. But, if she did, more power to her!

Anyhow, I say drive. One it is cheaper. Well, that depends. We live in a different direction than you, but about the same amount of miles. We do it straight through most of the time, but sometimes stop for the night. I definitely do NOT take 3-4 days to drive; that would be a colossal waste of time and would actually probably put you only driving 3-4 hours a day.

Here is an answer I gave not too long ago on another thread:

We always drive now. WE do two 24 hour (or close to) driving trips per year—one to WDW. We drive because it is cheaper with a family of 5, but also because we enjoy it. Never underestimate the power of having your own car when you arrive, especially if you have children in car seats and/or in a stroller. You have to have the right mindset: The point is to have a good time, not make good time. Then, be prepared.


Have portable DVD player if you don’t have a flip down. Can’t afford one? Use a laptop or borrow one. But do not bring it out until other activity options have been used. Also, have a turn off time; it can keep many kids awake at night.


Have favorite toys available and bring out some new ones. Give them to the kids every so often. They do not have to be expensive. Think dollar store. Put together a three ring binder that has different print offs—coloring pages, games (crosswords, picture bingo, etc. There are plenty of downloads/pintables on the internet; try to theme to your vacation). The binder makes a great hard surface for writing. Make sure to supply crayons/pencils/pens. Never underestimate the power of a magna doodle. Handheld video games also work wonders. Bring books on tape or read aloud yourself. Practice making up stories. There are several internet sites have great car game recommendations.


Have small trash cans available by each seat. Pack a roll of paper towels that is in easy reach. Bring a can of Lysol, Oust, package of baby wipes (you don’t need to have a baby to make great use of these), fabreeze, and maybe a roll of toilet paper. In baby aisles you can often find toilet seat covers, they might be well worth it. Amazingly, all of this stuff takes up very little room and can fit under a seat or in a small Rubbermaid container.


Have a pillow (travel/neck work best) and a throw blanket for each passenger, except the driver of course. It makes sleeping much more comfortable.


Stop often. I suggest every 2-4 hours for about 15-30 minutes. Do not get caught up in getting there. Again, the point is to have a good time, not make good time. It might add driving time to your trip, but it makes the trip feel faster. Everyone getting out and stretching keeps the crankiness away. Get out and eat when possible. Lots of rest stops have playgrounds. Fast-food places are great for this too. Or let the kids play while the adults eat (although adults running around are good for moral) and then have the kids eat in the car. Stop if you come across an item of interest. We did an impromptu stop at Graceland one time even though it was an hour out of our way; it was so much fun (surprisingly) and something we wouldn’t have done otherwise. Same with a trip to a unique museum and a tour of historical homes & civil war battlefield.


If possible, use a top of the car luggage rack if short on room in the vehicle. It will make everything feel roomier, which goes along way to make things pleasant. I suggest a hard top carrier; see if you can borrow one. The water resistant ones are OK, but place bags in trash bags before putting in the luggage carrier, just in case. I also suggest packing the clothes in the 2 gallon Ziploc bags under these circumstances. On the same note, duffle bags lend themselves to car travel much better than suitcases.


Inside your car, have a change of clothes for each person, two for the 3 and under set. Also, keep your toiletries in the car with you. This is also great if you stop for the night; you won’t need to go unpacking everything, just grab the overnight bags.


Bring food and snacks. A cooler is wonderful. You can pack healthy items. Stay away from caffeine and lots of sugar.


When you stop, clean out the car. Just do a big sweep to keep it clean. Fold up blankets and put away items as needed.


Time your trip right. For us, we leave late afternoon. The first driver gets a good nap during the day. We then drive until dinner. We get out for dinner and then hit the road again. The kids then sleep the bulk of the night. The first driver drives until tired. The passenger (second driver) naps. When the first driver is tired, switch. The first driver will then nap while the second driver drives. You must be honest though, you can’t drive if tired. If both drivers are tired at the same time, you must pull over and stop for the evening. When we go straight through, we stop at a rest stop in the morning and brush teeth and change clothes. Amazingly, nobody has ever been tired when we arrive. Part of that is the excitement of the trip ahead.


Another good theory is to get up and leave very early in the morning. The problem with that is that often time kids are then awake. It’s nicer to have them sleep through the bulk of the drive, if you are trying to go straight through. Still also, some leave at a normal hour in the morning and drive x amount of hours or distance and stop for the night at a predetermined spot. You can get a great deal on a hotel through price-line or other hotel discount sites this way.


Afraid your kids might jump out of the car? That is what child locks are for. Same with window locks. You might also want to think of joining an auto club—AAA is wonderful. But check with your car insurance; many offer car services with their policies that are good nation wide. Some car warranties also have them. Also, don’t forget that flying isn’t as fast as you think. You have to spend the time getting to the airport, checking baggage, clearing security, waiting for luggage, arranging for time to get to hotel, and there are possible delays and flight cancelations. Then you have to do it all in reverse! And if you get caught needing food in an airport, YIKES! That can be expensive with limited choice. You also have the cost of getting to the airport or paying for parking while you’re gone.

I just wanted to add that I have three boys--currently 7, 4 & 2. All of them had taken their first 24 hour drive trip by the time they were 4 months old (and still nursing). DS#3 even had to do a hurricane evacuation at 2 weeks old--a 4 hour drive that took 18 hours with the traffic. I had all three kids in my car, still recovering from the c-section. DH was with the dogs in his car.
One trip to WDW DS#1 was 4, DS#2 was 15 months and I was 6 months pregnant and we were in DH's (then) company car--a tiny Subaru. It was still a fun drive.

They look forward to the long drives because they are on an adventure. Oh, and we do not own a van; I am not the mini van mama type.
 
The best part of flying........we fly out in November at 725am and get there at 930am. There I said it. :cool1:
 
I am west of Nashville, TN, about 14 hours from WDW. I would not DREAM of flying--cost of plane tickets, cost of rental car, hassles of both.

We stay 1 night on the road each way. If I were going 19 hours, I would probably TRY to make it far enough to stay 1 night on the road each way. The tourbooks from AAA have lots of decent places to stay on the road. I am very good at looking through them to find the least expensive options at about where I want to stop. Last trip the two nights on the road cost about $100 combined.

Even though gas is alot higher than my last trip (March 2008) airline prices have gone up too because of jet fuel costs. I hate to hassel with airports, hate to have to adhere to their schedule, hate to hassel with renting a car, and think all of the above is more expensive than just driving (and there are only TWO of us to buy plane tickets for. I would not consider flying and not renting a car because I would feel helpless and controlled by the transportation schedule.

With my own car, if we are running behind (or ahead) of schedule we just leave when WE want to, going to where WE want to. I feel much more in control. Who cares if I leave the hotel at 7:15, 7:22, or 7:33. Or the house in the beginning for that matter. Also DW does NOT like the idea of flying, so convincing her to drive on vacation is easy. We split the driving and switch about every two hours. Its very pleasant.
 
I live about 12 hours from Disney. The price for the 5 of us to fly down was outrageous ($800 is a STEAL)! We are driving. We are leaving at 10pm and will arrive the next day at 10am. DH is sleeping the day before so he can drive while the girls and I sleep. On the way back we're driving during the day...we've got lots of coloring books, Leapster games and DVDs to keep them happy.

For $800, with a 2-day drive, I say FLY!!!
 
:wave: Hi, I'm from Indiana also! Danville now, but lived in Muncie for a while! We are going to drive down, we are taking a car seat, stroller and with 7 of us I am sure we will spend a fortune on the fees for luggage on the flights. I haven't looked at what route we will take or where we are going to stop, just know that I don't want to hit Atlanta during rush hour, so will probably plan everything around that!
 
i would probably consider driving from where you live. i live in the boston area, so theres no way i would even consider it unless it was just hubby and i. but, i really cant imagine driving home after the trip, that would be grueling.
 
We do and have done both. With 2 small kids and all they require it's sooo much easier to drive. We drive from the Midwest as well, about 19 hours with one nights stay over on each end. We still save money driving minivans and SUVs over flying and renting a car down there, we ALWAYS rent with the ages our kids are. Sometimes we have to fly due to timing resctrictions. I'm not sure they make a pill big enough that makes it feel tolerable taking 2 small kids thru an airport w/carseats, strollers, etc i kicked the carseat nearly all the way there one trip, that was awesome. Getting thru security stripping kids and getting your shoes off while holding a non-walking 18 month old was horried, the worst was the service i got flying alone w/a 5 month old and 2.75 year old.
 
My family did BOTH for our last trip. I hate flying and wanted to have a car while we were down there so I drove (20 hours each way) with 3 of our kids and DH (who couldn't take off extra days at work to drive and hates roadtrips) flew with the other 3 kids. I loved driving and he loved flying so it worked out great for us.We would've had a really hard time packing everything into the car if we all drove together though because we have a Durango and there isn't much trunk space left when you have 8 people in there. Dh would have hated driving because he doesn;t enjoy roadtrips at all, but I grew up going on roadtrips all the time and for me that's not a waste of time as a PP said, but part of the trip. To each his own I guess!
DH and I both agreed that having the car to drive to the parks was a huge bonus and much nicer than the previous trips when we spent a lot of time waiting for Disney transportation and lugging strollers on and off of buses.
 

New Posts


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom