I think that SOME of these reclassified rooms are real bargains. I just booked the aft equivalent of # 8520 (#8662) on the Dream last week after these cabins were reclassified. I compared the price to the old Cat 5B price and found that it was saving us $630 simply because of the reclassification! It was only a couple hundred more than booking a 9D and only about $100 more than the 8C family room. I studied all those same pictures very closely and decided that the obstructions (esp. on deck 8) were very minimal and that the ones on decks 7 & 8 look very similar to the old "secret verandah" cabins on decks 6 & 7 on the Magic & Wonder. I picked #8662 because I thought I'd rather be aft than forward and I wanted a non-connecting cabin and we only needed a room that slept 3.
I love finding a deal!!!!
(BTW if you click on the Cat 7A category on the
DCL website they actually picture one of these rooms with an obstructed balcony outside and I think it's probably a very good representation of what the better ones are like.)