We have stayed at both many times and while I prefer the location of the Dolphin I would rather stay at the POFQ because it is smaller and quieter and has a great food court, nice pool bar, great bus and boat service.
I have a similar problem...I have the POFQ booked for 10 nights in Oct but am hoping for the 40% off code that comes out in July so I can book YC or BWI. If the codes do not come out this year I can get the Dolphin for the same money as the POFQ. Since its F&W I would prefer that location but DH doesnt want to stay at the Dolphin for that long a time because of the lack of Disney feel.
But..he allowed me to book it for our Dec trip...go figure LOL!