If they treat requests as just unguaranteed preferences, what can they really do if at the time of check-in, those requests can't be met? If the resort is full, there is not much they can do. I would hate to be a CM trying to maintain a cheery disposition with a full resort and guests refusing to be put in certain rooms. Unless you can start paying extra to guarantee your preferences, you are plugged into an algorithm and rooms assigned accordingly. You always read on this thread, "request Jamaica 45", or whatever, well obviously not everyone is going to get Jamaica 45. I hope we get our requests, but in the end, I'll be happy to just be there and away from 3 feet of snow.
I agree...it must be hard to be a CM with a full resort and potentially LOTS of unhappy guests. I think for the most part, they try as much as they can to stay cheery. But they are only human.
I was wondering, as I'm new to this board (but a longtime "resident" of CBR):
1: how often do people actually not get a room at CBR when that is where they booked, and
2: how often are people moved to the Pirate Rooms being told it's an upgrade?
This is my first time there in the summer, and I have to say, I'm actually quite nervous about this happening to us. I would be extremely unhappy if I was put in the pirate rooms. Not because of location, (we rent a car so that's not a huge deal). We stayed in the pirate rooms in 2011 and I thought they were the most uncomfortable beds I had ever slept in. I was so miserable (as much as one can be in Disney of course

) that we almost called to see if they could move us to a regular room 2 days into our trip. I do not consider the Pirate Rooms to be an upgrade at all. The fact that they charge more for the worst rooms proves that WDW is being run by geniuses
Quite frankly, I was thinking about this last night after reading a previous post about this topic. I don't know what I will do if they want to move me to another resort. We love CBR so much and I know I would be quite unhappy with another mod. DS begged us for CBR because of the pool and nothing short of Stormalong Bay compares IMO and I'm sure that wouldn't happen. I know the deluxe resorts are beautiful, but there are a lot of them that really don't interest me at all. Each has their own great perks, but for every perk there's something I don't really like (except for Poly which is only a pipe dream for me).
Hoping that I don't have to deal with this, but would like to mentally prepare if it's a stronger possibility in the summer.
Thanks!!