We got back about 2 weeks ago and here was our take....
What we liked:
Theming was the best--adorable in the rooms, food court, main building, etc. A bit loud with the colors but very fun. We enjoyed pool hopping to get a feel for each pool. The Cozy Cone pool in the car section was themed the best.
Food Court--impressed with the food taste and quantity. Didn't have a bad meal. Also appreciated the large variety of choices for the refillable mugs. My sister was at the AKL, and their drink choices were fewer and not as good. Also agree that the take-out pizza was a great deal, and pizza was decent. Liked the real silverware and dishes.
Proximity to Pop--had fun walking to that resort and trying out their food court.
The beds-- more comfortable than what we expected after reading complaints on the boards. A bit firm, but still very comfy.
Bus Service--only used this 2 times, but both times it was quick and buses weren't too crowded.
Animation Drawing Class--we did this multiple times, we loved it so much! A definite highlight of our stay there.
Grounds: The foliage at this place was gorgeous! If you took the time to notice the change in plants from each section (jungle plants, sea type plants) it was impressive. Also, appreciated how the atmosphere and music subtly changed from themed area to themed area.
Activities--lots to do for my kids (teens and tweens), as it is as most resorts now.
What we didn't like:
Check-in--The person checking us in had the personality of a cardboard box, spoke so quickly I didn't understand her, and just seemed annoyed by doing her job. It was also noted on her name tag that she was a trainer (not a trainee). YIKES! We checked in before our room was ready, and she couldn't get our magic bands to work to open the pool gate. Took about 20 minutes and she still couldn't do it. Noted on our ressie that we were celebrating Jack's graduation and our anniversary, so she threw some pins at me (literally) and congratulated me on Jack's anniversary. I corrected her with a smile, and she said "Yeah, yeah. Sure." Was not a crowded check in time, so maybe she was having a bad day.
Cleanliness of our room--not good. Carpet not very clean, found a pair of dirty underwear in the bathroom from previous guests (ew), and found a child's bracelet and contact lens case under the couch (also not ours). No biggie, but I expected better.
The noise. We were in the Lion King Building closest to the main hall on the first floor, and our room was next to exterior doors. Any time those doors were opened or closed, all of our doors made a slamming sound and woke us up. We put heavy stuff in front of the main door, and kept the door to the queen bedroom open to make it quieter.
Music in Animation Hall/Main Building--Ok, this is going to sound like I'm a crazy person, but I will say it. They repeated the same 15 or so songs over and over. I don't know how anyone working there does not lose their minds. I'm a person who loves/notices music, but even my kids were wondering why they kept hearing Ashley Tisdale's version of "Kiss the Girl" for the 20th time.

Rant over.
Would we stay there again? Yes, but only for a few nights, not for a full week. Overall, the pluses definitely outweighed the minuses.