There is only one at each mall. The one on I-Drive closer to Universal is the one that was refurbed recently. The size of the store shrunk quite a bit as a result. In my experience, it really does vary from one trip to the next which has better selection. This past January, the one closer to Disney on Vineland had very little that interested me and the I-Drive one had better selection. Sometimes (most of the time for me) it's the other way around. Both parking lots tend to be a nightmare. If you have the time, visit both. If you only have time for one, I'd recommend the one closer to Disney on Vineland. On my last trip, I picked up a bunch of 2015 dated pins with Figment on them for 99 cents, which is perfect for pin trading. When I was in the parks the previous year, those same pins were about $12.