We just did a split stay at a value and a deluxe resort. The differences for us:
TOWELS! We got towels and trash service every second day at value. In addition to trash removal, there were piles of fresh towels and refreshed toiletries every single day at deluxe.
COFFEE!! At the value, we used the 2 coffees the first morning and the second day had no coffee left! The quick service wasn’t open until 7am, which was after we left for the park! It was a rough morning. At deluxe, we had keurig and more k-cups than we could possibly drink, refreshed regularly.
Balcony: we had a window at value, but a nice balcony at deluxe which we enjoyed quite a bit.
Quick Service: There seemed to be many more options for food on the quick service menu.
restaurants: there were at least 2 table service restaurants and a lounge and 2 pool bars open at the deluxe. Just the one quick service and one pool bar at value.
Pool Bars: The pool bar had full menus and real food and SERVERS TO YOUR LOUNGER at deluxe! At value we had to leave the gated pool area and go stand in 20-person line for each drink or pretzel (their only real food option).
Outdoor movie: this is a silly little benefit, but for the movie under the stars they put out actual chairs. At value everyone sat on the ground on towels.
POOL SLIDE! We thought our kids would like the value pool theming better but nothing could take the place ofslide. It added so much fun for our kids and kept them busy all day.
DESK! The biggest difference for my husband was having a desk to get some work done. Maybe some values have them but ours did not and he really loved that upgrade.
Crowds: Overall the deluxe resort just seemed less loud and busy and chaotic than the value. We waited in fewer lines and were able to find pool chairs easier, etc.
We really did like both resorts. I think the deluxe just felt more comfortable and relaxed. Like we were at a resort instead of a theme park hotel.