LL.....
I am so sorry you did not get POR or POFQ (which is the resort I really think you guys will love - but you already know that

). I am SURE that more discounted rooms will open up there, Those AP rates are really fickle. When I was booking CSR with an AP rate for my June trip I could NOT get an AP rate to save my life for Sat night, only Sun. When I called back for another reason I got the most awesome CM who made it happen and offered me the rate. That was like 3 weeks before my trip.
My point is....you WILL get POR. It is only October and you are going in January. Those general AP rates will open more rooms. I did not get the AP code either, though I wish I had.
However, I have stayed at CBR and Pop and for $34 more I would definately stay at CBR. I know it is not close to being your first choice, but in January it would be so pretty and tropical. Plus I bet the new pool remodel is nice and you will have Jen's car to get around the place, which is pretty big. You stand a good chance of getting a room really close to where you park the car. Big convenience there. Seriously, one thing I didn't like about Pop is walking to the car. Too far! (Boy am I a complainer).
Anyway - I know how badly you wish everything was all wrapped up with a nice neat bow, but you will just have to be patient a bit longer. Here's hoping pixie dust will come your way real soon.