Disney dining newbie - opinions on my ADRs

[melissarose]

so i've booked a bunch of ADRs for our february trip. i've never eaten at a sit down restaurant in disney before ... this is my first "real" trip. so any input on my ADRs would be appreciated!

here is the list:

Wolfgang Puck Cafe
Boatwright's
Crystal Palace
Tony's Town Square
Mama Melrose's
Yak and Yeti
Captain's Grille
Tutto Italia
Via Napoli
Portobello
House of Blues

I'm also hoping to do lunch at Be Our Guest because I REALLLLLLY want a croque monsieur, so i am hoping that it won't be so packed and busy in there that we can have lunch there.

 

[Southern Bell]

I haven't ate at all of them but I have at Crystal Palace and Tonys Town Square. I was pleased with both. My daughter liked Wolfgang Puck and I have eaten at House of Blues in Myrtle Beach and it was good there. Thats all I can help you with except to remind you to check the cancellation policy of each restaurant about how many hours you need to cancel before you are charged. I think I read somewhere they have changed some to 24 hours before reservation time. You may know all that but just thought I would mention it.

 

[goofyintoronto]

Wolfgang Puck Cafe - Only tried WGPE, not the cafe. Cafe doesnt get a lot of great reviews, but to each their own.
Boatwright's
Crystal Palace - LOVE IT! Always a great meal here, never disappointed.
Tony's Town Square - OMG DISGUSTING! Worst meal we EVER had in disney.
Mama Melrose's - I would avoid.
Yak and Yeti
Captain's Grille
Tutto Italia - OMG AMAZING! Best lasagna i ever had. Ditto for my sons fetuccini dish.
Via Napoli - OMG AMAZING! PHENOMINAL pizza here. WOW!
Portobello
House of Blues

 

[RCMommy]

Crystal Palace is a family favourite of ours. We ate at Yak and Yeti's a few years ago and found it okay, not as bad as some reviews it gets. I say try them all once and be your own judge.

 

[denneg]

Boatwrights is excellent, if you are staying at POR you might find yourself wanting to go back for another dinner! I haven't eaten at Captains Grille, but the menu is always intriguing. I've heard bad reviews of Portobello, but I've never eaten there. We are doing Crystal Palace for the first time this trip, but everyone loves it, so it must be good!

Some suggestions, if you are able to get them:

Teppan Edo is always fantastic.
Rose & Crown is really good, it was an unexpected great meal that we are returning for on our next 2 trips.
Ohana - If a miracle happens and you can get a table there, do it.

 

[melissarose]

thanks everyone!