My husband and I were just discussing this about an hour ago. For years, we went to WDW and didn't purchase the dining plan. For our June, 2006 trip, we decided to go for it. Man oh man am I glad we did.
We paid just a little over $800. I saved all the receipts and we ate over $1,400 in food!
I really liked the fact that everything was paid for before we arrived. I liked being able to eat anywhere we wanted. I liked being able to order anything off the menu and not worry about the price. We also tried different restaurants than we normally would have gone to.
I would suggest that you go to
www.disneyworld.com. In the search engine, type Magic Your Way with Dining. Click on the result. You will be able to pull up a brochure of each and every restaurant that participates in the dining plan. You won't believe how many there are. Print that out.
Then go to
www.allearsnet.com. Click on Dining. Scroll down to menus. There you will find menus for all the restaurants. The prices are also shown on the menus.
Pretend you don't have a budget and you could order anything you wanted from the menu. What would you eat? Also keep in mind that with a counter service meal, your entree, dessert and non-alcoholic drink are included. With a table service meal, you will get an appetizer, entree, dessert and non-alcoholic drink. Another plus of the dining plan.....you don't have to tip. It's included with the plan.
Oh and that snack you will want to buy mid-afternoon? It's included in the dining plan too.
I can honestly say that, if budget permits, I would never go to Walt Disney World without the dining plan again!
Hope this helps, Lisa