This belongs on the Dining Plan board so I am moving it.
I have never personally heard of anyone being offered a different menu anywhere because they were on the dining plan. There may be some menu items in certain places that were not included.
We plan to eat there on my birthday on our 2008 trip. We have never had any other TS places give us a special menu to use, I certainly hope they didn't start doing so.
Thanks for the answers. I was reading reviews on another website and the person was complaining (in their words) they were treated like second class citizens and were given a different menu because they were on the DDp and it got me worried. I am excited to eat at coral reefe for the first time though.