I have to agree just a bit with those who may not have thought that this fillm was just SOOOOO fantastic, as it was hyped up to be. YES - the CGI bacgrounds were completetely AWESOME!!!! And, as they said in the movie "Catch me if you can", it is easy to overlook things when 'looking at the stripes'.
1. Yes, the plot was lacking... Same plot as Toy Story, but NOWHERE near as entertaining. Also, to many just plain weird plot twists - a huge whale just appears completely out of the blue, unrelated to anything else in the story, and 'deposits' Nemo's father and Dory right smack in the middle of Sydney Harbor??????
2. Sorry, but this was also NO little mermaid... Where where the truly memorable characters like Sebastian, King Triton, and Ursula. Okay, Dory was GREAT!!! But that was definately due to Ellen Degeneres hilarious, very talented, and touching performance!!! Not due to the Character with a strange memory flaw?????? Heck, there was not even a big happy musical number like "Under the sea"?????
3. The characters themselves... Okay this is a childrens movie.... Characters like a neurotic dad, a sadistic dentist, a friend with a serious problem with memory loss.... And kids are supposed to enjoy this? Ummmm??????
As far as character development... They never did develop any sense of love and feeling between Nemo and his father. At least I did not think so. I can think of sooooo much that I would have liked to see in that regard. Where were the flashback scenes of the two of them in a close relationship together? Where were the scenes where they were both sorry about how they had contributed to Nemo being 'lost'? Oh, I know there was a slight comment or two... I am sorry, but I came away with greater feeling about the relationship between Dory and Nemo's father? Like when Dory pleads for him not to leave her.
4. The 'FUN' Factor... As I had read, No, Nemo never does have nearly as much fun 'under the sea' as Ariel did!!! Sorry, but a 5 year old simply just does not catch on to humor like "Sharks anonymous" There were very very very few scenes that were 'fun' for kids. Nemo smacking the boat when ordered not to... Going off to school riding on a big friendly ray.... Not enough to make a kids movie IMHO..... Sorry, but my DS (and the boy sitting next to him) had a complete BLAST and was happy and laughing all thru the trailers and stuff BEFORE the movie ever started... After that - nothing. Just fear of the scary parts.... DS walked out of the theater saying he wanted to see "Daddy Day Care" !
Okay, some may flame me on this... Hey that is okay... This is just my opinion... but here on the DIS I found this opinion obviously lacking, so I just had to thow this in.