Did VP Cheney endorse waterboarding and torture?

Naw, my method of revenge would be to strap them all into a 747 and send it sky high until it runs out of fuel then plummets to the earth and ends in a fiery crash.

But if the 747 flies until it runs out of fuel, there won't BE a fiery crash.

No fuel.................. um, er, uh ................... no fire.

Sorry.

P.S. - Pretty darned expensive way to kill 'em. A bunch of Greyhound buses off the side of a cliff will be lots cheaper.
 
JimB. said:
But if the 747 flies until it runs out of fuel, there won't BE a fiery crash.

No fuel.................. um, er, uh ................... no fire.

Sorry.

P.S. - Pretty darned expensive way to kill 'em. A bunch of Greyhound buses off the side of a cliff will be lots cheaper.

Oh you're right. Then just load the cargo bay with nitro.
 
JimB. said:
But if the 747 flies until it runs out of fuel, there won't BE a fiery crash.

No fuel.................. um, er, uh ................... no fire.

Sorry.

P.S. - Pretty darned expensive way to kill 'em. A bunch of Greyhound buses off the side of a cliff will be lots cheaper.
:rotfl: :rotfl2: You also lose a pilot in the process.

Do not point the lack of logic in john/charade's posts. You will just lose sleep :rotfl: :rotfl2:
 
TheDoctor said:
:rotfl: :rotfl2: You also lose a pilot in the process.

Do not point the lack of logic in john/charade's posts. You will just lose sleep :rotfl: :rotfl2:

The plane could be run by remote control.
 
Charade said:
Naw, my method of revenge would be to strap them all into a 747 and send it sky high until it runs out of fuel then plummets to the earth and ends in a fiery crash.

Sorry. I thought being an American made us different than the line of thinking that you suggest.

What's wrong with bringing those responsible before a court and having them answer to a court of law? (Re: Nuremberg )

I thought that was called Justice.

I thought that was a basic tenent of the United States.

I thought that is what separates "us" from "them".

Now understand this John and understand it well.....I want payback for 9/11 too and if I were to answer this with just my gut, you'd have to fight me to take the knife from my own hands to see which one of us would be the first to split those SOBs wide open....however, that is NOT what we are as Americans. We must advocate the basic foundations of law, however repulsive those in the docket are to us. Think how it must have been for the prosecutors at Nuremberg. We must rise above the animal instinct to met out simple revenge. We are Americans and as such we need to set a higher moral standard than the enemy. The world watches and history will judge us.
 
WonderfulDreamer2 said:
Hey, lets just put them up in the local Hilton and give them room service and keys to the mini bar until they just think we're so swell that they don't want to kill us anymore. I think that sounds like a brilliant idea. :thumbsup2 Then we can go up a few time a day and hug them and tell them how much we respect their right to hate and kill us infidels and how we really deserve it because we don't share thier beliefs. And after you get done, they'll give you a nicely wrapped package to take home to your wives and kids and as soon as you open it, you get blown to bits by the dirty bombs. Much better than waterboarding. :thumbsup2 We believe the terrorist before we believe our own service men and President. We would rather give the benefit of the doubt to Sadam than to anyone here in the US. Sugar and spice and everything nice is going to lead to the end of the US as we know it...and remember, you're the ones wanting to turn the other cheek, wich gives them the perfect opportunity to cut your throat from one side to the other. Have fun with them. :wizard:

That is lynch mob mentality and brings you down to the same level as those that have caused us so much suffering.

You surrender our values as Americans and befoul the sacrafice of those who have given their lives for this country. The blood spilled at Bunker Hill, Vicksburg and Omaha Beach wasn't given for us to cast aside like so much garbage simply because you are filled with so much vengance. No one here is advocating hugging any member of AQ or giving SH the benefit of the doubt. (who BTW IS on trial for his life ).

I don't want a single terrorist to go unpunished.

I also want to uphold this country's values of justice and due process that honors the sacrafice of Americans who have fallen in the past. I want us to act like citizens of the United States and not a pack of wild dogs hell bent on nothing but simple revenge.

To do otherwise would be to become what you abhor.
 
Judge Smails said:
That is lynch mob mentality and brings you down to the same level as those that have caused us so much suffering.

You surrender our values as Americans and befoul the sacrafice of those who have given their lives for this country. The blood spilled at Bunker Hill, Vicksburg and Omaha Beach wasn't given for us to cast aside like so much garbage simply because you are filled with so much vengance. No one here is advocating hugging any member of AQ or giving SH the benefit of the doubt. (who BTW IS on trial for his life ).

I don't want a single terrorist to go unpunished.

I also want to uphold this country's values of justice and due process that honors the sacrafice of Americans who have fallen in the past. I want us to act like citizens of the United States and not a pack of wild dogs hell bent on nothing but simple revenge.

To do otherwise would be to become what you abhor.
Got it, you think I'm wrong, and I think you are. I'm just thankful that you are not the one in charge of bringing anyone to justice. If that brings me to their level, then maybe it will be a level playing ground for a change. You may not be advocating "hugging" but you certainly as heck aren't advocating doing anything to get them to talk. It is war. War is nasty. People die. Its not a pretty fact, but a fact none the less. As usual, lets agree that we disagree on yet another political subject and leave it at that. My heart does not bleed tears every time a poor terrorist suffers a bit of discomfort or humiliation. After seeing the number of our soldiers that die at their hands, at the number of innocent people that have died on OUR SOIL because of their hate towards me because I don't believe as they do, after watching them take newcastersa and private contractors and physically abuse them and behead them on TV....I'm sorry, my compassion for them is long gone. Maybe there is special place in hell for me because of the way I think, but if there is, I'll buy you a drink when you get there.
 
AuntieM03 said:
On the one hand I have read here that these methods do not work, on the other I have heard that valuable information was gained that may have saved thousands of lives. So basically I am as confused on this issue as I am on so many others. If "torture" is not the answer how do we get the information that may be needed to stop future attacks?

Well, let's examine this:

You've heard from professionals who've said that torture doesn't work because the individual being tortured will say anything they think you want to hear. OTOH, you hear from people who have a vested in presenting themselves as competent and on top of the situation, for example, the Bush administration, tell you they've saved thousands.

So your choices are: Are you going to believe the professionals or the armchair generals?

And how do you get information from someone? How do police do it, across this country, every day? Why not ask them?
 
JimB. said:
With all due respect, in this regard you are just slap - a** wrong.

I guess it depends on your definition of torture. That's an easy way to justify something that is wrong. No scars = no torture. So I guess holding battery cables to someone's testicles does not equal torture either?

How about a woman in a psychlogically abusive relationship?

Also, the time I witnessed it, my friend had a massive nosebleed for about 15 minutes after he was UNSTRAPPED from the board. Most likely due to an acute increase in his blood pressure from the PHYSICAL and MENTAL stress.

Soooooooo, I'll guess we will be doing stroke screenings prior to slappin' people down, eh?? It's OK, then?


BTW, for a great little discussion on the value of torture, check this out:

http://www.philosophers.co.uk/cafe/provocations20.htm.

A couple of tidbits:

extensive studies of torture show that it is largely ineffective as a means of gathering correct information...............

as history and basic human psychology show, most people will say almost anything to end terrible suffering. For example, a former prisoner from Abu Ghraib told the New York Times that, after being tortured, he confessed to being Osama Bin Laden to put and end to his mistreatment.................

Be careful, Jim. You're right on the edge of being classified as a terrorist sympathizer, in league with the terrorists, an enemy of the US, and a candy-*** who just doesn't understand how things work in the post 9-11 world. And if you think your years of service count for anything with these people, guess again.

While the first time is a shocker, after a while you get used to being labeled because you know it's bull**** from people who couldn't find their *** with both hands and a mirror.
 
VampHeartless said:
The line between "us" and "them" just gets thinner and thinner with this administration.

We've met the enemy and he is us.
 
TheDoctor said:
:rotfl: :rotfl2: You also lose a pilot in the process.

Do not point the lack of logic in john/charade's posts. You will just lose sleep :rotfl: :rotfl2:

And a potful of time that can be spent much more productively, but wouldn't be as entertaining. ;)
 
WonderfulDreamer2 said:
Got it, you think I'm wrong, and I think you are. I'm just thankful that you are not the one in charge of bringing anyone to justice. If that brings me to their level, then maybe it will be a level playing ground for a change. You may not be advocating "hugging" but you certainly as heck aren't advocating doing anything to get them to talk. It is war. War is nasty. People die. Its not a pretty fact, but a fact none the less. As usual, lets agree that we disagree on yet another political subject and leave it at that. My heart does not bleed tears every time a poor terrorist suffers a bit of discomfort or humiliation. After seeing the number of our soldiers that die at their hands, at the number of innocent people that have died on OUR SOIL because of their hate towards me because I don't believe as they do, after watching them take newcastersa and private contractors and physically abuse them and behead them on TV....I'm sorry, my compassion for them is long gone. Maybe there is special place in hell for me because of the way I think, but if there is, I'll buy you a drink when you get there.


After seeing the number of our soldiers that die at their hands, at the number of innocent people that have died on OUR SOIL because of their hate...

Seems as if you didn't get the memo;

Iraq had nothing to do with 9/11.

I'm sorry, my compassion for them is long gone

Mine too. Please don't infer that because I advocate American justice rather than a viceral act of revenge that I am somehow compassionate for the terrorists.

It is war. War is nasty. People die. Its not a pretty fact, but a fact none the less.

According to this line of thought it would have been acceptable practice for our American airmen to fly Kamakazi raids against the Japanese fleet during WWII.

It would have been an acceptable practice to have rounded up every German and put them into the gas chambers after the fall of Berlin.

Please note the following list of Islamic terrorist organizations:

Islamist Terrorist Organizations
· Abu Sayyaf (1991-present; Islamist separatists; the Philippines)
o Based in the southern islands of Jolo, Basilan, and Mindanao.
o Branched off of the Moro National Liberation Front.
o Allegedly partnered with Jemaah Islamiyah and Al-Qaeda.
· Aden-Abyan Islamic Army (Yemen)
· Al-Gama'a al-Islamiyya (Late 1970s-present; Islamists; Egypt)
o Seeks to establish Islamist state in Egypt. Usually targets secular establishments, government buildings, police, the military, minorities, tourists, and “morally offensive” buildings.
· Armed Islamic Group (1992-present; Islamists; Algeria)
o Seeks to establish Islamist state in Algeria. Began operations in 1992 after the Algerian government ignored election results that gave victory to Islamist political parties.
· Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades
· Ansar al-Islam (December 2001-present; Islamists; Iraq)
o In Arabic, "Supporters of Islam."
o Also known as "Partisans of Islam or Helpers of Islam."
· Al-Qaeda (1988-present; Islamists; Afghanistan, Pakistan, and worldwide)
o In Arabic, "the foundation" or "the base."
o Also known as Qa‘idat al-Jihad, Islamic Army for the Liberation of the Holy Places, World Islamic Front for Jihad Against Jews and Crusaders, Islamic Salvation Foundation, and the Osama bin Laden Network.
o Related: Alneda (former web site), As-Sahab (affiliated public relations organization),
o Cells: Buffalo six, Hamburg cell,
· Asbat al-Ansar (early 1990s-present; Lebanese Sunni Islamists; southern Lebanon)
o In Arabic, "the League of the Followers."
o Acronym for "Harakat al-Muqawama al-Islamiya," or Islamic Resistance Movement.
· Jama'at al-Tawhid wa'al-Jihad/Al-Qaeda in Iraq - Abu Musab al-Zarqawi's Sunni network, operating in Iraq
o on U.S. State Department list of Foreign Terrorist Organizations
· Eastern Turkestan Islamic Movement - al-Qaeda linked separatist group in China's Xinjiang Autonomous Region aiming to establish an Islamic state. Banned by China, along with related groups Eastern Turkistan Liberation Organisation, World Uighur Youth Congress and East Turkistan Information Center [3]
· Egyptian Islamic Jihad - Egypt (active since the late 1970s)
· Hamas - Israel, West Bank, Gaza Strip. Listed as a terrorist organization by Australia, Canada, the European Union, Israel, and the United States
· Harakat ul-Mujahidin (HUM) - Pakistan and Kashmir
· Hezbollah - Lebanon; attacks Israel and advocates its destruction
· Hizbul Mujahideen - Pakistan and Kashmir
· Hofstad Network - Netherlands
· Islamic Front for the Liberation of Bahrain - Defunct
· Islamic Movement of Central Asia - Central Asia
· Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan - Uzbekistan
· Jaish-e-Mohammed - Pakistan
· Jaish Ansar al-Sunna - Iraq
· Jemaah Islamiyah - Southeast Asia
· Jihad Rite - Australia (linked with Al Qaeda. Founded in 2001)
· Lashkar-e-Jhangvi - Pakistan
· Lashkar-e-Toiba - Pakistan
· Lord's Resistance Army Christian/Pagan/Muslim terrorist group that operates in northern Uganda, it seeks to overthrow the Ugandan government and create a country based on the ten commandments.[9]
· Maktab al-Khadamat - Afghanistan - Defunct
· Moroccan Islamic Combatant Group - Morocco and Spain
· Moro Islamic Liberation Front - (Islamic separatists; the Philippines)
· Palestinian Islamic Jihad - Israel, West Bank, Gaza Strip
· People Against Gangsterism and Drugs - South Africa
· Salafist Group for Preaching and Combat - Algeria
· Sipah-e-Sahaba Pakistan - Pakistan
· Takfir wal-Hijra - Egypt/Sudan/Algeria
· Kurdish-Hizbullah - Turkey
Islamist Fronts
· Al-Barakaat (Al-Qaida front)
· Al-Wafa Humanitarian Organization (Al-Qaida front)
· Benevolence International Foundation (Al-Qaida front)
· Global Relief Foundation (Al-Qaida front)
· Holy Land Foundation for Relief and Development (Hamas)
· Konsojaya Trading Company (Jemaah Islamiyah front)

These organizations are based in the following countries/areas


Yemen
Egypt
Algeria
Iraq
Lebanon
China
Israel
West Bank
Gaza Strip
Kashmir
Netherlands
Central Asia
Uzbekistan
Southeast Asia
Australia
Morocco and Spain
South Africa
Sudan/Algeria

If the statement by bush that we are fighting them there so we don't have to fight them here applies, then why haven't we invaded these 17 other countries/areas to protect America and kill the terrorists?

Is every Islamic terrorist organization based in Iraq?

What is the bush administration doing to protect us from these terrorists organizations?

Why haven't we invaded China or the Netherlands?

2% of all insurgents in Iraq are foreign based. All the other insurgents are Iraqis. There are more Islamic terrorists in Southeast Asia than in Iraq, why haven't we invaded Southeast Asia too?
 
Does the use of torture by the US bother anyone?

Yes it does. It bothers me. Not because I feel sorry for terrorists, but because the USA is supposed to be above such behavior.
 
Judge Smails said:
Seems as if you didn't get the memo;

Iraq had nothing to do with 9/11.



Mine too. Please don't infer that because I advocate American justice rather than a viceral act of revenge that I am somehow compassionate for the terrorists.



According to this line of thought it would have been acceptable practice for our American airmen to fly Kamakazi raids against the Japanese fleet during WWII.

It would have been an acceptable practice to have rounded up every German and put them into the gas chambers after the fall of Berlin.

Please note the following list of Islamic terrorist organizations:

Islamist Terrorist Organizations
· Abu Sayyaf (1991-present; Islamist separatists; the Philippines)
o Based in the southern islands of Jolo, Basilan, and Mindanao.
o Branched off of the Moro National Liberation Front.
o Allegedly partnered with Jemaah Islamiyah and Al-Qaeda.
· Aden-Abyan Islamic Army (Yemen)
· Al-Gama'a al-Islamiyya (Late 1970s-present; Islamists; Egypt)
o Seeks to establish Islamist state in Egypt. Usually targets secular establishments, government buildings, police, the military, minorities, tourists, and “morally offensive” buildings.
· Armed Islamic Group (1992-present; Islamists; Algeria)
o Seeks to establish Islamist state in Algeria. Began operations in 1992 after the Algerian government ignored election results that gave victory to Islamist political parties.
· Al-Aqsa Martyrs' Brigades
· Ansar al-Islam (December 2001-present; Islamists; Iraq)
o In Arabic, "Supporters of Islam."
o Also known as "Partisans of Islam or Helpers of Islam."
· Al-Qaeda (1988-present; Islamists; Afghanistan, Pakistan, and worldwide)
o In Arabic, "the foundation" or "the base."
o Also known as Qa‘idat al-Jihad, Islamic Army for the Liberation of the Holy Places, World Islamic Front for Jihad Against Jews and Crusaders, Islamic Salvation Foundation, and the Osama bin Laden Network.
o Related: Alneda (former web site), As-Sahab (affiliated public relations organization),
o Cells: Buffalo six, Hamburg cell,
· Asbat al-Ansar (early 1990s-present; Lebanese Sunni Islamists; southern Lebanon)
o In Arabic, "the League of the Followers."
o Acronym for "Harakat al-Muqawama al-Islamiya," or Islamic Resistance Movement.
· Jama'at al-Tawhid wa'al-Jihad/Al-Qaeda in Iraq - Abu Musab al-Zarqawi's Sunni network, operating in Iraq
o on U.S. State Department list of Foreign Terrorist Organizations
· Eastern Turkestan Islamic Movement - al-Qaeda linked separatist group in China's Xinjiang Autonomous Region aiming to establish an Islamic state. Banned by China, along with related groups Eastern Turkistan Liberation Organisation, World Uighur Youth Congress and East Turkistan Information Center [3]
· Egyptian Islamic Jihad - Egypt (active since the late 1970s)
· Hamas - Israel, West Bank, Gaza Strip. Listed as a terrorist organization by Australia, Canada, the European Union, Israel, and the United States
· Harakat ul-Mujahidin (HUM) - Pakistan and Kashmir
· Hezbollah - Lebanon; attacks Israel and advocates its destruction
· Hizbul Mujahideen - Pakistan and Kashmir
· Hofstad Network - Netherlands
· Islamic Front for the Liberation of Bahrain - Defunct
· Islamic Movement of Central Asia - Central Asia
· Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan - Uzbekistan
· Jaish-e-Mohammed - Pakistan
· Jaish Ansar al-Sunna - Iraq
· Jemaah Islamiyah - Southeast Asia
· Jihad Rite - Australia (linked with Al Qaeda. Founded in 2001)
· Lashkar-e-Jhangvi - Pakistan
· Lashkar-e-Toiba - Pakistan
· Lord's Resistance Army Christian/Pagan/Muslim terrorist group that operates in northern Uganda, it seeks to overthrow the Ugandan government and create a country based on the ten commandments.[9]
· Maktab al-Khadamat - Afghanistan - Defunct
· Moroccan Islamic Combatant Group - Morocco and Spain
· Moro Islamic Liberation Front - (Islamic separatists; the Philippines)
· Palestinian Islamic Jihad - Israel, West Bank, Gaza Strip
· People Against Gangsterism and Drugs - South Africa
· Salafist Group for Preaching and Combat - Algeria
· Sipah-e-Sahaba Pakistan - Pakistan
· Takfir wal-Hijra - Egypt/Sudan/Algeria
· Kurdish-Hizbullah - Turkey
Islamist Fronts
· Al-Barakaat (Al-Qaida front)
· Al-Wafa Humanitarian Organization (Al-Qaida front)
· Benevolence International Foundation (Al-Qaida front)
· Global Relief Foundation (Al-Qaida front)
· Holy Land Foundation for Relief and Development (Hamas)
· Konsojaya Trading Company (Jemaah Islamiyah front)

These organizations are based in the following countries/areas


Yemen
Egypt
Algeria
Iraq
Lebanon
China
Israel
West Bank
Gaza Strip
Kashmir
Netherlands
Central Asia
Uzbekistan
Southeast Asia
Australia
Morocco and Spain
South Africa
Sudan/Algeria

If the statement by bush that we are fighting them there so we don't have to fight them here applies, then why haven't we invaded these 17 other countries/areas to protect America and kill the terrorists?

Is every Islamic terrorist organization based in Iraq?

What is the bush administration doing to protect us from these terrorists organizations?

Why haven't we invaded China or the Netherlands?

2% of all insurgents in Iraq are foreign based. All the other insurgents are Iraqis. There are more Islamic terrorists in Southeast Asia than in Iraq, why haven't we invaded Southeast Asia too?

You have got to stop confusing people with facts. :stir:
 
It's not just Cheney that is ok with torture. This piece of legislation was passed last month:

The Senate, following the example of the House of Representatives, passed legislation that allows the president to authorize: the indefinite detention of those the administration chooses to label "enemy combatants;" the systematic mistreatment and abuse amounting to torture by any reckoning except that of the current administration; and suspension of anything resembling legal due process, including the right of habeas corpus, i.e., the right to challenge the legality of one’s detention or treatment in front of a judge rather than a military tribunal.
The legislation does more than that. It also provides amnesty for any violations of the Geneva Convention’s ban on cruel, inhumane and degrading treatment committed or ordered by any agent of the U.S. government after Sept. 11, 2001.
 
LuvDuke said:
You have got to stop confusing people with facts. :stir:

Here's another fact to confuse people:

On June 7, 2006, Abu Musab al-Zarqawi,the leader of Al-Qaeda in Iraq, was killed 1.5 miles (2.41 km) north of Hibhib, near the city of Baquba, Iraq, by a United States air strike, along with as many as eight other people, including women and children.[22] He died from internal bleeding at 7:04/05pm, 50-55 minutes after the air strike, of injuries sustained in the bomb blasts.[23] FBI tests later confirmed Zarqawi's identity.

Thus proving that it is not necessary to occupy a country in order to kill terrorists.
 
Oreo Cookie said:
Doc - Thanks for the updated information. It's good to know that the military is rejecting the toture methods that Dawn is advocating.

I don't support the CIA and waterboarding. The CIA is an extention of our government and they too should be living by the terms of the Geneva convention.
I have been pleased with the professionalism of the JAG corp on this issue. Despite extreme pressure, the JAG lawyers have stood up to Rummy, bush and Gonzales by refusing to sanction torture and violations of the Geneva Convention. These officers have shown great courage. One JAG officer has been in effect fired for honoring his professional obligations by defending a detainee and taking the case to the US Supreme Court.

Our military officers overall have been very professional and have done the right thing. The problems that have occured are due to Rumsfeld and the people who think that it is not torture unless you kill or cause organ damage. Thank G-D, Gonzales had to drop that legal position.
 
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061104/ap_on_go_ca_st_pe/terrorism_detainees

By MATT APUZZO, Associated Press Writer

WASHINGTON - A suspected terrorist who spent years in a secret CIA prison should not be allowed to speak to a civilian attorney, the Bush administration argues, because he could reveal the agency's closely guarded interrogation techniques.

Human rights groups have questioned the CIA's methods for questioning suspects, especially following the passage of a bill last month that authorized the use of harsh — but undefined — interrogation tactics.

In recently filed court documents, the Justice Department said those methods, along with the locations of the CIA's network of prisons, are among the nation's most sensitive secrets. Prisoners who spent time in those prisons should not be allowed to disclose that information, even to a lawyer, the government said.

"Improper disclosure of other operational details, such as interrogation methods, could also enable terrorist organizations and operatives to adapt their training to counter such methods, thereby obstructing the CIA's ability to obtain vital intelligence that could disrupt future planned terrorist attacks," the Justice Department wrote.

The documents, which were first reported by The Washington Post, were filed in opposition to a request that terror suspect Majid Khan should be given access to an attorney. Khan, 26, immigrated from Pakistan and graduated high school in Maryland.

According to documents filed on his behalf by the Center for Constitutional Rights, Khan was arrested in Pakistan in 2003. During more than three years in CIA custody, Khan was subjected to interrogation techniques that defense attorneys suggest amounted to torture.

President Bush acknowledged the existence of the CIA system in September and transferred Khan and 13 other prisoners designated as "terrorist leaders" to the military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Under a law passed last month, they are to be tried before special military commissions and may not have access to civilian courts.

The Center for Constitutional Rights is among several advocacy groups challenging that law. They say the Constitution guarantees prisoners a right to challenge their detention.

The Justice Department argues that civilian courts no longer have jurisdiction to intervene in the case. They say keeping details about the CIA program secret is essential because national security is at stake.

"Information obtained through the program has provided the United States with one of the most useful tools in combating terrorist threats to the national security," the government argued in court documents.

"It has shed light on probable targets and likely methods for attacks on the United States, has led to the disruption of terrorist plots against the United States and its allies, and has gathered information that has played a role in the capture and questioning of senior al-Qaida operatives," it said.

Gitanjali S. Gutierrez, an attorney with the Center for Constitutional Rights, responded in court documents Friday that there is no evidence Khan has classified information. Gutierrez accused the administration of using national secrecy concerns to "conceal illegal or embarrassing executive conduct."

U.S. District Judge Reggie B. Walton has not indicated when he will rule.
 
Uncle Remus said:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061104/ap_on_go_ca_st_pe/terrorism_detainees

By MATT APUZZO, Associated Press Writer

WASHINGTON - A suspected terrorist who spent years in a secret CIA prison should not be allowed to speak to a civilian attorney, the Bush administration argues, because he could reveal the agency's closely guarded interrogation techniques.

Human rights groups have questioned the CIA's methods for questioning suspects, especially following the passage of a bill last month that authorized the use of harsh — but undefined — interrogation tactics.

In recently filed court documents, the Justice Department said those methods, along with the locations of the CIA's network of prisons, are among the nation's most sensitive secrets. Prisoners who spent time in those prisons should not be allowed to disclose that information, even to a lawyer, the government said.

"Improper disclosure of other operational details, such as interrogation methods, could also enable terrorist organizations and operatives to adapt their training to counter such methods, thereby obstructing the CIA's ability to obtain vital intelligence that could disrupt future planned terrorist attacks," the Justice Department wrote.

The documents, which were first reported by The Washington Post, were filed in opposition to a request that terror suspect Majid Khan should be given access to an attorney. Khan, 26, immigrated from Pakistan and graduated high school in Maryland.

According to documents filed on his behalf by the Center for Constitutional Rights, Khan was arrested in Pakistan in 2003. During more than three years in CIA custody, Khan was subjected to interrogation techniques that defense attorneys suggest amounted to torture.

President Bush acknowledged the existence of the CIA system in September and transferred Khan and 13 other prisoners designated as "terrorist leaders" to the military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Under a law passed last month, they are to be tried before special military commissions and may not have access to civilian courts.

The Center for Constitutional Rights is among several advocacy groups challenging that law. They say the Constitution guarantees prisoners a right to challenge their detention.

The Justice Department argues that civilian courts no longer have jurisdiction to intervene in the case. They say keeping details about the CIA program secret is essential because national security is at stake.

"Information obtained through the program has provided the United States with one of the most useful tools in combating terrorist threats to the national security," the government argued in court documents.

"It has shed light on probable targets and likely methods for attacks on the United States, has led to the disruption of terrorist plots against the United States and its allies, and has gathered information that has played a role in the capture and questioning of senior al-Qaida operatives," it said.

Gitanjali S. Gutierrez, an attorney with the Center for Constitutional Rights, responded in court documents Friday that there is no evidence Khan has classified information. Gutierrez accused the administration of using national secrecy concerns to "conceal illegal or embarrassing executive conduct."

U.S. District Judge Reggie B. Walton has not indicated when he will rule.

Small wonder Bush is gadflying all over this country for Republicans. He's running ****-scared that people are going to be elected who'll lift up the Bush rock.
 
TheDoctor said:
Luckily Dawn does not speak for the military. The US Military has specifically rejected the torture methods that Dawn is advocating.

It is only the CIA who is supposed to be using waterboarding.


i don't recall advocating that the military conduct interrogations. it is the responsibility of the CIA which has the expertise in this area.
 

Loading WDWINFO articles...

Dreams Unlimited Travel
Before You Book Disney, Get a Free Quote
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners help you compare resorts, tickets, packages, discounts, dining, and cruise options. There is no cost to use our planning services.
Request a Free Vacation Quote
Walt Disney World · Disney Cruise Line · Disneyland · Adventures by Disney
-





DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom