We've stayed deluxe & moderate & we loved POP. I think all the hotels at DW offer a unique experience & not one of them is bad. POP has a great theme & my kids loved the pop jets. The food court was crowded at peak times & especially after park closing. The quiet pool in the 50s section was not crowded during the day & we were able to find plenty of lounge chairs. This was August & the resort was at full capacity. Rooms were a bit small, but I didn't think significantly smaller than a moderate. We were fine as a family of four. People complain of thin walls, I didn't notice any noise. Maybe we were lucky & had great neighbors? Oh & the bus service was great, we never waited more than a few minutes at POP but leaving the parks, the lines were usually long but moved quick. If the bus was standing room only, we just waited for the next one which was always right behind. Anyway, just MHO but I don't think a Quality Inn, Motel 6, or whatever hold a candle to the beautiful pool & bar area, friendly CM's and wonderful theming. Don't expect a huge room, valet parking, or room service & you will have fun!