Delish Dining, May 19-May 25

:banana: I'm really enjoying your reviews. Can't wait to read more.

We stayed at POFQ last Dec & fell in looove with the ben-gays too:cool1:

Cindy's Royal Table sounds like fun, we might have to try it on our next trip if we can get in.


It really was fun in the Castle...if you're really into Magic Kingdom, you just can't skip dining in the castle once in your life! (Or more) But at least once.
 
We slept in again, after our later night at the Adventurer’s Club we needed it. Had our last foray with the beignets…missing ‘em already! Then we headed back to DHS for a brief visit, mostly just to see Beauty & the Beast stage show (couldn’t fit it in on Friday.)

Boy were we disappointed…we thought we’d be getting there right in time to see the first performance Saturday a.m. only to find out there was a high school choral competition going on the stage so no B & B show until late afternoon!

So, we wandered around a bit, trying to decide whether to go try another park right then. Happened to remember that the new Toy Story Mania was supposed to open that day, so we headed back to see if it had. We really lucked out here! There were no FastPasses yet, but there was only a 20 minute wait so we hopped in line. Thought it would be too much like Buzz Lightyear at MK...NO COMPARISON, folks. Toy Story Mania is way, way, way better.

Anyway, back to food! DD & BFF went to ride TOT one last time, so DH & I decided to take a break at the tables by Catalina Eddie’s, since that’s right down the street from TOT & on the way out of the park. All the tables have umbrellas, so it’s a nice shady spot on a hot day. Well, the smell of food “overcame” us before the kids got back, and even though we intended on eating lunch elsewhere, we decided to stay & eat.

DH & I both had double cheeseburger & fries, and chocolate fudge cake, with bottled water from Rosie’s All-American. We found the burgers & fries to be good, definitely a notch up from McD’s. The choc fudge cake, while it was the little pre-packaged kind, was moist, fresh & tasty. It is not as good as the variety of desserts found at the bakery places (like Starring Rolls) but these little cakes were tasty. As we’ve noted on Disney meals, the portions on the burger & fries were large enough that we barely could finish the dessert, anyway.

Have to say: I don’t know what people are expecting when they come away so disappointed with this CS, but we found the help to be fast & efficient and the food to be good. These aren’t gourmet burgers by any means, but they are better than the usual fast food outside the WDW. We liked the fries - they were hot & fresh, and ample portions. (If you’re dying for McD’s fries, though, you can go right next door and get the real thing at the McD’s fry stand. Which we saw people do…one family of 5 near us chose to do just that….their entire lunch was 5 extra large orders of McD’s fries & large cokes…nutrition didn’t exactly match the food pyramid, but what the hay, they’re on vacation, right?)

DD & BFF returned from TOT, and they opted for Catalina Eddie’s. DD chose the pizza (I did tell her that people say Disney does a terrible job on pizza everywhere, but having just survived freshman year at college, she’s fairly certain that no one can do worse than college food.) She chose pepperoni pizza with a side salad, lemonade, and the choc fudge cake. Said the pizza was good enough, not horrid by any means. Said it was at least two steps up from dorm food, and better than a good frozen pizza (she likes frozen pizza, LOL.) She’d get it again. She also liked the choc cake, but was unable to finish it. BFF chose the Caesar chicken salad, diet coke & apple pie. He liked the chicken salad but was not impressed with the pre-packaged apple pie. Said it was more like an apple crisp, and just not that good. But he was full from the salad, anyway so no biggie.

So, we liked the food from these two CS places. Must be the prices that make people expect gourmet-counter food, cuz we just didn’t think the food was bad at all. It’s not fancy, but good enough American fare, we thought. Yes, the prices are higher than what you'd pay outside WDW, but typical for amusement-park-captive-audience-prices. We’d go back if we found ourselves at DHS for a 2nd day again.
 
So, our final table service restaurant was the California Grille at the Contemporary Resort, which we were really looking forward to. We had the first sitting (at 5:30) and we did check in early…shortly after 5:00, because we’d heard that was your best bet for getting a window table. Although we weren’t the first people there, we were maybe the 4th or 5th party checking in.

Anyway, after sitting in the lounge area watching the waiters scurry around setting up tables, we were seated - at a window table- right at 5:30. It should be a very nice view from there - it’s all windows - but they have the blinds closed “until the sun goes down.” Now, they are light-filtering blinds, so you can kind of see through them but not really. What’s the point of having this fab view if you can’t really see anything? Well, about ½ way through the meal, they did put the blinds up about 6 inches. So if you kind of scrunched down in your seat, you had an unobstructed view. Still…was kind of disappointed by that whole set-up. I guess you have to go for a late seating/dusk to see anything…course then it’d be a short time before dark when the view would disappear again, so WTH?

Now, the Cali Grille is a fairly posh place…the kids had a great time doing the drop-jaw routine at some of the prices on the wine lists ($100 a glass!) But we’re just not that into wine, or spending that kind of money on a 3 oz beverage. So we skipped that expense (we really wouldn’t have paid that much for a glass of wine even if we were into wine!) I did however have one of my frozen fruity thingies…just a regular pina colada this time, and DH had a Corona.

For our main courses, 3 of us chose the Oak-fired beef filet, which was served with fresh steamed asparagus and a grits-cake that had some sort of fancy name on it. BFF chose some type of fish (want to say it was one of the Pacific islands types with a Hawaiian sounding fish name similar to mahi-mahi, but cannot remember for sure, and the online menus are not correct about the fish offered last week.) He liked it, but said it was not the best he’d ever had.

Now, I’m sure this is going to be sacrilege to some, but I have to say the beef filet was good… but just good. Not fabulous. Not outstanding. Just good. It was cooked correctly, it did have a nice little sauce on it. Frankly, I would never in a million years pay $38 for this dish had we not been on the Disney Dining Plan. Both DH & I felt it did not come close to Le Cellier’s filet (which we would pay the cash price for, any day of the week.)

The asparagus served with it was delish…actually cooked to perfection (not soft & mushy, like so many places do it) The grits-cake thing was just spicy corn grits, compressed into what resembled cornbread, but not nearly as good…not real impressed. DH liked it, but DD & I basically took one bite and said “WTH? Don’t think so.”

So, after enjoying, but also being a tad disappointed with the entrees, we ordered desserts, going for four different desserts & planning on sharing bites. After the little let-down on the steaks, we figured the $10 desserts weren’t going to be all that, either. So, I got the Honey crunch cake, DH got the Butterscotch & Bananas, DD got some sort of molten chocolate Cake with fresh Apricot Sorbet & BFF got some other sort of triple chocolate tower something or other (don’t remember the exact names on these things, & the on-line menus I find do not list the exact same desserts we saw offered last week. Don’t know how often they change the menus there, but most of what we saw on the menus was somewhat different than what’s listed on the online version.)

So, back to the food. O.K., THE DESSERTS WERE ABSOLUTELY 100% OUTSTANDING. So good, that everyone wanted to keep their own & not share! So we all grudgingly gave up tiny tastes to our tablemates, but oh, we all savored these. The only thing that did not wow everyone was the fresh apricot sorbet—taste was just way too strong (more like stewed apricots, frozen.) But the cake with it was oozing this incredible chocolate sauce, so that made up for it. The rest of the desserts were start-to-finish-lick-your-plate good. After, we went out on the decks to see the incredible view , take pictures (and watch lightening off in the distance.) A very fitting end to a week of Disney Dining Plan. They told us to hang onto our receipt, we could come back & watch MK fireworks from the deck that night, but we chose to stay in the park for the fireworks instead.

Would we go back to California Grille…probably not. On the DDP, it takes 2 table service credits, which we just did not think the main entrees warranted those prices. And though the desserts were spectacular, I wouldn’t use 2 credits to get them! And since the awesome view was mostly obscured by the blinds during the meal, the location didn’t justify the price for us either. But, it was good, and it was something we had to try once. And really, maybe if we’d done the California Grille first - before Le Cellier - we would probably have enjoyed the Grille more. Who knows…anyway, that's the last food report of my trip...after the Cali Grille, we caught the monorail over to the Magic Kingdom, to finish out our WDW vacation in the most magical place on earth…and even though it rained quite a bit that night, the rain magically stopped long enough for us to see Spectro Magic for the first time in more than 10 years...we had a great view near the end of the parade route (over across from Splash Mountain. Not near as many people as near Main Street & Castle viewing spots.) That was quite the magical way to end our trip!

But guess what? DH & I are returning to WDW in September for a birthday trip…and all our ADR’s are at different restaurants. So lots of new things to try & review! Until then, pixie dust to all!;)
 
Loved the trip report!! You have just convinced me to try Cindy's for dinner!
Hopefully we can go Dec 2009!:)
 

Thanks for the reviews! I look forward to more in September! Have a great time!

Bummer that CG was a dissapointment. We've always had wonderful meals there. :goodvibes
 
Thanks, people. I hope to have pictures with reviews in September (forgot the camera most of the time in May, and the one time I did remember to take it out, DD obviously thought that was too silly...so I backed down! She won't be with us in September, so we can be as "embarassing" as we want:lmao:)

You know, CG wasn't really a "bad" meal, it actually was good...we just didn't think it was worth the prices/2 TS credits. If a couple of things about it were different, it would probably have made it a much better experience (such as something besides that grits-cake thing with the steak...what's wrong with some form of potato? And also if the blinds had been opened so we could enjoy that incredible view. I know they change the menu often-as I said, I found 2 different supposedly recent menues on-line, and neither was the same menu we saw in May. At least 1/2 of the items had at least part of the description different. So maybe the next time we'd go they would have the blinds open, or the latest menu change would appeal? Who knows.)

I would still suggest to other it's worth trying the place...
 
Loved reading your reviews!!! We're trying CRT for breakfast for the first time in August. After reading your report, I can't wait. Thanks!!
 
Loved reading your reviews!!! We're trying CRT for breakfast for the first time in August. After reading your report, I can't wait. Thanks!!

Have fun...I've read that breakfast is busier & noisier, but also has princesses! Hope you do reviews, too. We may try some breakfasts on our 2009 trip (that is, if I can convince DH we need to go again in 2009!;) )
 
For the frozen adult beverage lovers out there, I can clear up the name of the mystery drink...

Thanks to Robert P from NC posting on another thread, I learned the name of that wonderful version of pina coladas we had from the outside drink stand at Morocco: It's called the "sultan's colada", and the almond flavor is actually almond liqueur...no wonder it was sooo good!;)

We will be returning there in September for sure, especially since I'm told it's even hotter & more humid than late May is, so we'll need frozen relief! (We also mean to try those slushy drinks from France and I swear we will get around to trying some bakery delights too.)

Can't wait for Labor Day!:yay:
 
see you in France @ the bakery for chocolate croisants in SEPT!!!! ;)
 
would love some, DrDeb!

:offtopic: I see you have MNSSHP listed...is it worth it for 2 adults? What's the advantages? I'm considering it...DD & her BFF just did the PPP in May (they're 19 year olds) and had an absolute blast, so now I'm thinking maybe DH & I are missing something special if we don't try the MNSSHP?
 
Great reviews! I didn't realize that if you kept your receipt that you could watch the fireworks from their deck. Hmmmm... maybe we'll go there and just get a couple of desserts one night and then catch the show!
 
Great reviews! I didn't realize that if you kept your receipt that you could watch the fireworks from their deck. Hmmmm... maybe we'll go there and just get a couple of desserts one night and then catch the show!


Those desserts would be worth it...they were superb. I would say there's plenty of room on the deck for a crowd to watch (more space than tables, that's for sure) And I'm sure most people do not come back. It would be an awesome view, without the exiting park crush!
 
O.K., last thing on my reviews. DH did a cost comparison of what our out of pocket costs would have been on all our snacks, lunches & dinners (using actual costs for what we ate) versus the cost we paid on DDP (tip excluded, since it varied - "cost" is just what we would have paid cash for everything we ate.)

For each of us (DH & I), cash OOP would have been $234.33, or $468.66 total for both of us. What we actually paid: $189.95 x 2 = $379.99. So DDP saved us $88.67. Not astronomical savings, but it was a savings. And we found it very convenient, and really enjoyed being able to order whatever sounded good.

DD & BFF did not keep all the receipts, so I can't reconstruct actual costs on her room DDP, but it had to be close because they ate with us for all table service except one (they had Crystal Palace the night we had Hollywood & Vine...CP is similar cost) and they also ate at all the same counter service except the day we ate at Earl of Sandwich they were at Typhoon Lagoon for lunch.

Course, there's the big debate about "but would you have gotten the same foods without the DDP"...honestly, we probably would. Ordinarily, we do not have dessert very often, either at home or in restaurants (actually very rare, except birthdays & holidays.) But when we're on vacation, we do like to splurge as part of the overall vacation experience, so I don't think we would have skipped the desserts.

I will say the DDP was just the right amount of food. We rarely nibbled at any snacks in between meals (often used one snack for breakfast beignets, then split the other snack in the park.) There's no way I'd sign up to do the deluxe dining plan-we'd be throwing away food/leaving plate fulls on that. It would just be way too much food for us.
 














Save Up to 30% on Rooms at Walt Disney World!

Save up to 30% on rooms at select Disney Resorts Collection hotels when you stay 5 consecutive nights or longer in late summer and early fall. Plus, enjoy other savings for shorter stays.This offer is valid for stays most nights from August 1 to October 11, 2025.
CLICK HERE













DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest

Back
Top