I think this is the typical response to wiping away debt quickly. Remember the adage "change is a process, not an event." If you just take the money out of the IRA, not only will you be paying penalties and negatively impacting your retirement, but you aren't going through the process of change for your finances. So, it is very likely that in the big picture, you will be even worse off. The same is usually true of consolidation loans. While it may seem daunting, re-paying the debt over years will force you to change spending/budgeting practices, and that will be what will ensure your financial future.
I don't know what the specifics to your debt are, but if you can work out a re-payment plan on your own, you will be so much better off in the future. Start with the Dave Ramsey techniques (list the debts, attack the smallest and then snowball the others) by finding money in your current budget and/or increasing income with additional jobs, selling things, etc. Attack those negative, sabotaging thoughts that are telling you you can't do this. You will feel so good about your accomplishments in the end!
I agree 100%!!!!!!!!!!!!!!






THIS! My sister did this and although it's a bit different here in Canada...it didn't work out the way she had intended. In the end she realized it was a bad move. I suggest looking into all other options first to see if anything else can be done. This would be a last resort measure in my mind.
If you don't have an emergency account...perhaps the best thing to do is to cobble one together so you don't have those things come up that destroy the best laid budget plans. THEN get serious about that debt.
Six years ago, DH and I refinanced our mortgage and rolled the credit card debt into it just to get rid of it and start fresh. After a year we were right back where we started from (had charged the card back up again) except that we STILL had the extra money rolled into the refinance. I know it's tempting to just "get rid of it" but it's not always the best way.
Are there any professionals you could get advice from?
We did this too. It makes the credit card balances show 0 but it doesn't change our ways of thinking or spending vs. saving money. Really, it's dangerous.
I liken the whole pay down process to losing weight. If we needed to lose 40 lbs and went out and got liposuction we'd be happy but we never really changed our ways of eating/exercising so the weight is eventually gained back. Only through the old fashioned, slower way

of eating less and moving more, making sometimes painful lifestyle changes, do we learn to change the behaviors that got us in that situation to begin with.
At what point does it hit us that something has to change?

When we need to lose 10 lbs or 100 lbs? When we need to pay off $1000 debt or $40,000? You know when you reach that point you have to change your ways. When you need to lose 100 lbs you might think, "This would have been so much easier if it were only 10 lbs." but back then we were not uncomfortable carrying the extra 10 lbs and it was not enough to make us change our ways. Likewise, when it was only $1000 in debt, we were still ok with that. Wouldn't it have been much easier to pay down when it was still only $1000? Yes, but it didn't strain our budget and it was not uncomfortable to carry that $1000. Only when it starts to feel uncomfortable do we see it as a problem. Then we ignore it a while because we don't want to face facts.
Now I'm dealing with it head on, smacking it in the face and getting it out of my life.

We all want to believe that if only we had a higher paying job it would be so much easier but realize that EVERYONE has a budget, regardless of what you earn. Sometimes the more you make, the more debt you'd be comfortable carrying.
(When I say "you" I don't direct this to anyone in particular.)