Currently have 8526 and 8554 on the Magic. Which one would be more quiet?

[Tucker24]

Traveling with mother in law on the Magic who is very picky about accommodations. One room is on deck 8 under the quiet adult pool while the other room is under Pinocchio's pizza area. Do you think they would hear less noise under the restaurant or quiet pool? After reading the reviews it is mixed on whether the deck chairs will be a noise issue. Right now we have rooms 8526 and 8554 but i can change 8526 to 8556 if under the restaurant would be more quiet

 

[Mushu's Twin]

I've personally stayed in rooms Forward, Midship, and Aft on deck 8 on both sides of the Magic and have never had any problems with noises. Also anywhere you are on deck 8, there's gonna be some sort of deck chair or table and chairs above you. Also if you don't know, Pinocchio's isn't really a restaurant in my opinion, it's a quick service counter. Where they'll get their food and take it to tables and chairs the same as the deck chairs which will still be right above your room.