I think you are being unfair. Everyone who knows me here knows I am a
Disneyland Resort Hotel person, but we have stayed at Hojos. Compared to some of the other off property hotels in the area, you would be LUCKY to stay at Hojos. There is a reason why it is rated highly on TripAdvisor.com and here on the Disboards--and it has to do with the fact that you get value for your money. One person came her annoyed with her 59.00 (!) room, and complained about it. It is her right to complain, but not everyone feels this way. I knew I didn't want to to stay in the room near the freeway, so I paid 79.00 (amazing entertainment rate), and got a Disney facing room. It was perfectly fine--great bed, view of the Matterhorn. I thought I was lucky to get it. I actually think those rooms are worth more. The other hotel I stayed at on Harbor wasn't nearly as good.
And I didn't see the manager as coming here and "making excuses"--there are so few hotel (motel) managers that would come to a message board to personally answer a customer complaint. This is actually very unusual and some good, personal customer service! If you are a regular on this board, you know that many people here have stayed at Hojos and give it very good marks, so letting one person's bad review influence your perception just is not that well thought out.
Let us know how you like your hotel. Which one did you decide to stay in?
For me I think it is worth it to stay on property if at all possible--but not everyone agrees with that.