I am having a hard time reading through some of these. I have been an avid pin trader for YEARS and the quality of pins coming out of the actual retail establishments of Disney has taken a NOSE DIVE. To read through these and accuse people of selling BAD PINS when NO ONE can be 100% sure of authenticity makes me ill. I understand that there are sellers on ebay that sell scrapper pins, and I am not refuting that point....but MANY of the TRUE AUTHENTIC PINS NOW HAVE JAGGED EDGES, DIPPS IN PAINT, BRUSH STROKED IN THE ENAMEL AND DO NOT HAVE THE BOARDER OF MICKEY' HEAD ALL THE WAY TO THE EDGE OF THE BACK OF THE PIN.
Businesses are HURTING now from threads like these. I know it's human nature to warn people of danger. I don't want to waste money any more then the next person. But I PLEA to you, if the sellers don't have a return/refund policy....then DON'T BUY from them...if they do, what do you have to lose? I have purchased from sellers on the good AND the bad list. There are some of your "Bad List" sellers who send out great pins that seem just as legit as the next one. And what does it take to be on that good and bad list of yours? ONE person saying they had a bad experience? If we all went on ONE good or bad experience then EVERY place would be out of business because there are a lot of people that arn't happy no matter WHAT you do...and these are the people depriving you of a great deal?? How does that make sense??
There would be an explanation on the FIRST THREAD of these "Good and Bad Seller" lists that that it is the OPINION of the people purchasing, not the end all-be all that people on the "GOOD" list ONLY sell "great pins" and the people on the "BAD" list only sell scrappers.
If it is that big of a deal to you, they only buy directly from Disney when you are at the parks, or on the cruise line. Otherwise, you are paying a discounted price, you are taking that risk. Why so shocked when you don't get $15 a piece pins in lots of 25 for $10 TOTAL???? Makes no sense to me.