As far as dinner go, I think that both are decent. I do like that Cinderella and the step sisters are at 1900 Park Fare. They add some fun and entertainment while you eat. However, Crystal Palace is much prettier in my opinion and people feel more spread out so it doesn't sound as noisy. We just felt like the tables were a little close at 1900 and the noise was a little loud at times. I don't think you can go wrong either way.