I am not sure if you are referring to breakfast or dinner. We had dinner at both on our last trip.
I noticed many bad review for H&V on this site, but I think it is a reminder that you need to form your own opinion.
We enjoyed both on our last trip. The food was about the same. The characters and the environment make CP a better choice.
If you were referring to breakfast I have not done either one, but will be doing them both in December.