In Sept/early Oct, it was my birthday & the kids' first visits. I added both celebrations on every dining reservation. I usually got a cupcake for my birthday, but the kids did not get anything. With the exception of 'Ohana dinner & maybe Chef Mickey's breakfast. So I wouldn't expect anything, except maybe an acknowledgment from CMs. DD wouldn't wear her 1st visit button for long since it bothered her. DS1 was too young to wear his!