I've done both. The princesses are the same, as well as the interaction you get with them. The only difference is the price and the food. I personally don't like breakfast foods, so for me the lunch was better (although I wasn't crazy about those food choices either; I had the Major Domo's pie; it was okay, but not something I'd go out of the way for.) My brother loves breakfast food, so he liked the breakfast much better (plus it was cheaper.) I would base your decision on the menus, and whether or not you want to "waste" a morning doing breakfast.