I love this thread. I'm supp to be getting the kids ready for school, but I'm too busy LOL at this thread. I can soo relate! I appreciate all presents, but I laugh inside at a few. Here are some recents:
The 1st year I dated dh, his very frugal dad got me a wall corded phone previously used reboxed with gum on the cord. For a few years I got previously used gift (inc. like food gift sets stored for a year, I checked the exp date

), but he now gives me money, lol.
DH tries, but some gifts are sooo funny. One year was a pack of granny panties way too big, I didn't want to hurt his feelings & wore them to sleep in. I finally told him the next year that I didn't wear that style, so he picked me out some low low rise juniors felix the cats. I wear natural colored makeup & get french pedis, but I'm not brand picky. DH got me a HUGE makeup case with very color of the rainbow eyeshadow & nailpolish (and its the 2nd time I got one of these

). I could go on... I have a standard safe xmas list- B&BW, Lane Bryant cert., pedi certificate, and socks and would be happy to get the same thing every year, but dh says my list is boring and won't shop from it!
Some interesting gifts I've gave....I'm a very pratical person who can be creative on limited funds though I usually gift good gifts unless otherwise requested. My dad wears 5X & always asks for boxer briefs which are hard to find in local stores, so thats always in his gift bag. My MIL visited with us & didn't know my dad/g-parents try on everything to make sure it fits, not a shy bunch. Still LOL at her turning around & seeing my dad's new gift! I've also have got him cigs & lighter pack by request. My mawmaw asked for a good new bra one year, so I obliged (same year as mil visited)-yep she made sure it fit. My younger sil always complains about what I get her while I'm still in the room, one year was a tommy juniors babydoll shirt, one a nice $50 perfume sampler, another makeup brand she wore & lip gloss, soooo 2 years ago I wrapped her a pretty box with a poem with the 12 pads of Christmas included with 12 packs of Carefree thong pantyliners (which she wears-CVS ecb deal). It was a joke since she never likes or uses what I buy, though I did get her a bottle of B&BW & soft socks too. The funniest part was instead of looking inside & closing the box, no she keeps pulling them out of the box looking for something else maybe, I was rolling in the floor. Her dogs have ruined her apts carpet, so I bought a neutral 5x7 rug same color as the carpet, but again verbal complaints until I said I can give it to someone who will like it. She complained as MIL opened real pearl earrings I bought her, said mom don't you have enough jewelry! Geesh!
Keep 'em coming, I love these!