This year will be our first Christmas WDW trip so we haven't done the CP dinner package yet, but we are going to this trip. We try to budget wisely and not go overboard on meals at WDW, but this will be an exception for us. While the meal alone will not be a bargain, when we weighed all the issues involved we still decided it was worth it. My DH wanted to try San Angel Inn this time anyway, and so that is where we'll get the package. It will be a more expensive meal than if we just ate there normally, but our family is not much for waiting in line so that right there is worth some of the extra expense. Plus, we love Mouse Gears so I'll be able to recoup some of the expense while shopping there. And we usually make a couple of purchases from the countries at WS, so that will also help. All in all, when you add up the meal, the shopping discount, nice (covered) seats, and the time not wasted waiting in line, I'd say it's well worth it!