We always had the cheeseburger because of the toppings bar. After reading on here about the rib and chicken, that is now our favorite and a "must do" every time we go. Kids love the chicken nuggets and using the topping bar for cheese to dip!
My husband and I split the rib/chicken meal on out April trip. It was very good! The green beans were awesome, the ribs were well seasoned as was the chicken and the potatoes were just plain yummy! We usually get the cheeseburger or hot dogs there, but wanted to try something different and we were pleasantly surprised.
The rotisserie chicken meals are all pretty tasty and quite large. Two reasonable eaters can easily split one.
Cosmic Ray's used to serve arguably my favorite chicken Caesar salad anywhere. It was hand-tossed and made with a garlicky homemade dressing. Now the dressing comes from a pouch, and it is served on the side. I usually prefer salad dressing on the side, but with Caesar salads, I like it mixed in.