We stayed there the last week of August after changing our reservation from Yacht Club because of a great deal at CSR. Blew us away, we instantly fell in love with the place. Beautiful grounds and architecture. Gorgeous views across the lake. Who doesn't love a 50 foot tall Mayan pyramid waterfall next to their swimming pool? The Pepper Market food court is really above average. You get not one but two table service restaurants as well, one of which is Signature dining and the other of which is a second option for breakfast. A trendy inside lounge. A lakeside bar. A pool bar with really long hours that also serves breakfast. (As in, three breakfast options!) And bus service with really great travel times to all the parks that doesn't get shared with any other resort.
We stayed in a preferred room in August and will stay in a preferred room again in December. Those are in the first three Casitas buildings connected to El Centro. Business class in Cabanas 9b is a great option, though, because you get a complimentary continental breakfast in the business class lounge in the morning and complimentary snacks, beer, and wine in the evening.
Some people would suggest that you don't want a room in the Ranchos section because it's the farthest section from El Centro. It's not located around the lake but kind of a little bit beyond the lake. But you can always take a theme park bus to El Centro and a Disney Springs bus back to your room.
There's a room renovation going on beginning any minute now and continuing until next December. But they'll be closing buildings individually, one at a time, so it really shouldn't impact anyone.
The thing about CSR is that, because it's one of Walt Disney World's convention resorts, although it's a Moderate resort, it has amenities similar to a Deluxe resort. At no other Moderate will you find, all together in one resort, a food court and two table service restaurants, three bars including a pool bar that serves food and maintains morning to late-evening hours, and a spa and health club. The food and bar options will completely ruin you for Port Orleans Riverside or French Quarter. The bus service will ruin you for CBR. The only thing missing is live entertainment.
My partner and I figured that after our first stay at CSR, we would want to start rotating our trips around all of the moderates. While we were there though, we decided that CSR was going to be our home resort unless we splurged for a Deluxe. Even then, it would have to be Animal Kingdom Lodge or we would just stay at CSR again.
Our not so humble opinion.
