I am going to WDW the first week of December 2011 and it was originally going to be me and my BFF....when I go with her we usually stay at POP because its the cheapest and we like it the best of all the values. BUT, I just found out she may not be able to go anymore due to money issues. Which would be a really bad thing EXCEPT for the fact that my parents (who went with me in 2009) have decided that they really want to go back. So if she ends up not being able to go this year, they have already said they will go with me.
That being said, in 2009 we stayed at CSR for the first time and absolutely LOVED it. I was quite surprised at that, mainly because we aren't into the southwestern/desert/mexico/mayan look, etc. In fact, we only chose it because it had recently been redone with new queen beds and my mom said there was NO WAY she was sleeping with my dad (who flops around like a giant fish when sleeping) in a double bed. Lol! Anyway, in the early 90s, which was the last time they had gone, we stayed at POR. I was looking around the other day thinking that maybe we should stay at POR because dad would just LOVE that there was a boat going to DTD and he would be taking it all the time (
he just loves boat and train rides, its quite funny). But I looked at the pics of the grounds and well, they just didnt do anything for me! I dont know if it was because it just reminded me of the old days, back when WDW was not really my thing because we only knew to go to one park and we didnt know what we were doing and thus it held no good memories for me, or what. And THEN I looked at my CSR photos I had downloaded from this thread onto my computer in 2009 when I wanted to sell my parents on the resort (hope that was ok, ya'll had some great photos) and I was like, ahhhh! So pretty! I fell in love all over again with the fountains and the color of the casitas buildings and the greenery and the check-in building.....I don't think I'm going to ever be able to stay at different moderate ever again.
P.S. Just as an aside, I have also stayed at CBR (I think it was early 2000's with my friend's family) and it didn't really do anything for me either. Go figure! I guess I am officially a CSR gal!

So thanks to all of you who have posted pictures and told about the resort over the years, especially KatMark who started this thread which I first found mid-2009, because if it hadn't been for ya'll I never would have given CSR a chance!!!!