FWIW...our dinner at the Coral Reef last week was the worst dining experience we've had at WDW ever. I had been to CR once before for lunch and was lukewarm about it. I thought we'd give it another try this trip, and it was truly terrible. I'll have to write a full report, but here are a few highlights...
1. Our waitress was TICKED OFF that we wouldn't order dessert as we ordered our apps and entrees. We prefer to linger a bit and never order dessert until later in the meal. She threw the menus onto the table and said "well, try and look them over soon".
2. When I ordered the catch of the day, which had a truffle oil on it, she said "Um, do you really want the truffle oil?" I said I did. She informed me "Just to let you know, it smells really weird". With such a high recommendadtion from the waitstaff...who could pass it up?? I DID get it with the oil and it actually was quite tastey.
3. The restaurant was LOUD. I know I'm in WDW and I expect noise and kids at all my meals. But the noise level in here was like Chuck E. Cheese on a Saturday afternoon loud. I couldn't take it and had a splitting headache by the end.
I have to say it's rare for me to complain about WDW restaurants. I have pretty reasonable expectations. But this experience was just bad. I say, enjoy the booths instead.