I agree that if you're not in love with CCV, it doesn't necessarily make sense to pay higher direct prices for it. We love it and knew we wanted to buy CCV but did not consider BRV for a number of reasons (prefer to be in main building for the holidays, contract twice as long, more modern style, more types of accommodations, immediate access to points). If you love WL but things like that don't matter to you, BRV resale might make more sense. If you prefer another resort entirely, resale is definitely the cheaper way to go (but be prepared for it to take significantly more time).