So I should just keep both

Me either until this friend told me about it. I have just been worrying about coordinating my purse, shoes, and belts.
I really like that one as well except my department store was sold out of it. I thought the small one was a little too small myself and I already have a large one from a couple years ago. Enjoy your bag
I was thinking about getting the scribble. Good to hear that the dirt is coming off with mild soap in water as that is what I was told as well
I really liked the patchwork as well, but they were out of it
Thanks to everyone for all of the replies and votes. I'm leaning towards the white one. I forgot to mention in my OP that the bag is of a weather-resistant fabric so if any dirt or anything gets on there it should wipe off with some ease. I'm not as worried about it working into the fall as I have quite the shoe and handbag addiction and I have a lot of blacks and browns for fall. I should have mentioned that I have this Hamptons bag (the largest one) from two years ago as well:
And this is my only bag with white on it (Cole Haan from 2004):