We did both meals last week. Of the 2, I much preferred the Princess Storybook Lunch at Akershus to Cinderella's Gala Feast at 1900 Park Fare. When planning the trip, I expected my reaction to be the opposite.
the Gala Feast was much noisier and my dislike of buffets came out again... that does need to taken into consideration

The character interaction was very good, my DD5 was concerned about meeting Prince Charming, but he did a great job of chatting quietly with her and winning her over. The mice were cute and came back to our table 2 or 3 times, we saw Prince Charming and Cinderella once each, Fairy Godmother was in the lobby.
Akershus was a zoo to get into, there is this enormous hot, hungry, tired of waiting outside in the sun mob of people and strollers at the entrance. Once they called our name, we quickly got to meet Ariel and then were seated. The noise level was much lower than at 1900 Park Fare, we had a better server and it was a much more relaxing meal. We had been through the cold buffet when the other 4 princesses (Belle in blue dress, Mulan, Jasmine, and Aurora) came around. It was nice that we were able to meet them all before our hot food came. I'm sure this was dumb luck (Pixie dust?

) on our part but it worked well. We all enjoyed our food - the kids meals are traditional favorites, DD7 had grilled chicken and buttered pasta (instead of mashed potatoes), DD5 had the pasta and meatballs with marinara. Both girls ate well. I had the leek soup and open faced salmon sandwich, DH had the kjottkake (salisbury steak, mashed potatoes and veggies).