When I saw the title of this thread, I immediately thought of this & got nervous
I have a soft spot for that castle overlay . . . it's equal parts "WHAT were they THINKING?!?" and also pure whimsy. I wish I could have seen it!
My first ever visit to WDW was in Nov of 96, and back then you didn't get advance notice on the internet saying
"Hey! The castle looks like a cartoon cake straight outta Candy Land! Just a heads up!" Nope, unless you knew someone that was there with pictures/video, you had no clue since it was apparently only done that month before. I had that vacation planning video from 1995 (the one in the pink box with Goofy on it lol), and all I saw every time I watched was a regular Cinderella castle. It hyped me up. My 7 year old self was too giddy to handle. I practically ran into the park ready to see this majestic marvel that was "the castle at Walt Disney World". It was like what you see in commercials with the little kids having their dreams come true.
Then I saw the castle in the ^ above form and stopped dead in my tracks. I was incredibly confused.
I went again in July of 97, saw the castle was still a derpy cake, and was 1000% convinced it was gonna stay like that forever. My now 8-year-old mind was that much wiser with experience, clearly.
For years to come I felt I got robbed of the true Disney experience. As I'm older though, I'm actually glad I saw this in person. I feel like I'm part of a semi-exclusive club that gets to say
"Yeah, I saw this! I WAS THERE! It's indeed real!" It's something that most likely will NEVER happen again to that magnitude (since apparently it was so disliked? Personally I would've been livid if I walked in on the Stitch Castle. That just looked trashy compared to this lol). I mean, it WAS the 90s, guys and gals. Not too many things were safe from the style and spectacle of the 90s, especially not Disney.
Anyways, as to what I think of this recent announcement of the makeover for the castle, I think it looks alright, it could'be been MUCH worse, at least it still looks regal. The dark blue portion they're 'adding' isn't really gonna be new though. I believe the castle had a paint job a few years ago, and it was that dark blue color then. It's just the Florida sun faded it so much that it no longer looks that way. So I think they just added that in to take the opportunity to retouch it, not necessarily related to Cinderella's 70th anniversary.
I'll be in MK on Sunday, so as long as they don't add any scaffolding/skrim/cranes/etc until March 1st, I'll be okay. It's been 10 years since I've been there, it'll be my birthday, please WDW, cut me (and the rest of us out there) some slack.