Depends on your eating habits. If you will just get an omlette then its probably cheaper to order off the menu. But I always get the buffet since for me its about variety. I like to have several different things, in smaller portions. And then also my daughter can eat enough fruit for 5 people, no fruit plate off a menu could be enough for her! Also, they will make a specialty omlette on the buffet, I asked for an egg white one and they made it no problem, my son asked for fried eggs and again, no problem. So if you want something special, they are happy to do it. Often, by the time you order a beverage etc., sometimes it doesn't save as much as you think. For example I always get juice and ice tea and they are both included in my buffet price. Also, I like to get a small bowl of oatmeal, an eggwhite omlette and a bunch of fruit with my two beverages. If I did that a la carte, I'd be spending way more. But for some people its the exact opposite. I agree, look at the buffet then decide, you might want to sample a few different things once you see what they have.