Chinese Gymnast Too Young for Olympics??

Is China sneeking in 2 Underaged athletes to the games

  • Yes and they should be aloud to compete

  • No

  • Yes and they should have to replace the athletes with age elligible athletes

  • Yes and the Chinese gymnastics team should be aloud to compete


Results are only viewable after voting.

disneydance

DIS Veteran
Joined
Feb 18, 2007
Messages
6,632
As I'm a gymnastics freak I've been hearing about this ever since a Chinese reporter wrote He Kexin was only 14 and you must be 16 to compete in the Olympics. What are peoples opinons on this. I've heard so much about it that has said there too young that I do believe there too young. There are many statements that were made before 2008 for He Kexin and 2006 for Jiang that said they were both born in 1993 and 1994. So do you think they should be alloud to compete?? Discuss

Too young for Beijing? Posted Sunday, July 27, 2008 11:49 AM ET

Getty Images
According to some news reports, Jiang Yuyuan, who won the Olympic Test Event last year, could be as young as 14. She's listed as 16 on her passport. BEIJING(AP) - Two female Chinese gymnasts, including a gold-medal favorite, might be too young to participate in the upcoming Beijing Olympics.

Several online records and reports show He Kexin, the host nation's top competitor on uneven bars, and Jiang Yuyuanmight not yet be 16, the minimum age for Olympic eligibility. Both were chosen for China's team last week.

On the Web site of the Chengdu Sports Bureau - Chengdu is the capital of Sichuan province in southwest China - a file dated January 2006 shows He Kexin as being born Jan. 1, 1994.

Most recently, a May 23 story in the China Daily newspaper, the official English-language paper of the Chinese government, had He's age as 14.

The newspaper story begins: ``The 14-year old newcomer to the national team, who was recruited last year, has raised a lot of eyebrows recently after she broke two world records on the uneven bars in as many months.''

Photos
Photos: Jiang Yuyuan



Related Stories
He Kexin bio
Jiang Yuyuan bio
The New York Times raised questions about the athletes' ages in a story Saturday. And Chinese officials provided the newspaper with copies of passports indicating both gymnasts are 16.

But in a speech on Nov. 3, 2007, in the central city of Wuhan, Liu Peng, director of general administration of sport for China, said: ``The 13-year-old uneven-bar gymnast He Kexin, who defeated national team athlete Yang Yilin - she just won the bronze medal in the world championships - has demonstrated her ability.''

To be eligible for the Cities Games where Liu made his remarks, Chinese documents show athletes must be over 13, but under 15.

The New York Times reported International Gymnastics Federation officials acknowledged questions about He's age had been raised and asked the Chinese for clarification in May.

``We heard these rumors, and we immediately wrote to the Chinese gymnastics federation,'' Andre Gueisbuhler, the secretary general of the international federation, told the newspaper. ``They immediately sent a copy of the passport, showing the age, and everything is OK. That's all we can check.

``As long as we have no official complaint, there is no reason to act, if we get a passport that obviously is in order.''

The American and Chinese women are expected to battle for the team gold medal when the Beijing Games begin Aug. 8.

He is one of the few athletes in the world who has scored over a 17 under the new scoring system. Using He and Yang Yilin, who also has scored a 17 on bars, the Chinese hope to use the uneven bars to build up a big advantage in the team competition.

The Americans, who won the 2007 world championships team title, have only one gymnast, Nastia Liukin, who's gotten a 17 on bars.

If gymnasts He, a gold-medal favorite, and Jiang are under age, it would be yet another black eye for China in the buildup to the games.

In June, Chinese swimmer Ouyang Kunpeng and coach Feng Shangbao were permanently banned from the sport after Ouyang tested positive for anabolic steroids. Wrestler Luo Meng and his coach also were barred for life for a doping violation by the athlete.

The Chinese government is working feverishly to present a positive image of an open, friendly, progressive nation. But visa restrictions, toxic air pollution, freedom of the press issues and a problem-filled torch relay have presented a far different image to the world.
 
I heard about this too.
I personally think it's stupid that they are too young to compete.
If they have enough experience, and skill I think they should be fine.
 
I heard about this too.
I personally think it's stupid that they are too young to compete.
If they have enough experience, and skill I think they should be fine.

I think they should be aloud to compete but its not fair to other countrys as they have ready athletes like America(Rebecca Bross, and possibly Jordyn Weiber, and Sam Shapiro), and Canada(Peng Peng Lee) but are not aloud to compete due to there too young and there following the guidelines.
 
I don't think that because they aren't 16 they shouldn't compete. If there good enough why not? I knew one girl who was getting looked at for the american team along while ago before she was 16...but then she got an injury and well can't do gymnastics anymore but really if they have talent then let them in.
 

I don't think China should be allowed to have an underage athlete if the other countries can't.
 
If the US listens to the guildlines for the Olympics (so I've been told at least) then so should every other country. If you're too young, you're too young.
 
If the US listens to the guildlines for the Olympics (so I've been told at least) then so should every other country. If you're too young, you're too young.

Thats what I was thinking on one gymnastics forum I go on we were jockingly saying if all the FIG wants is a passport that says a athletes is born in 1992 or earlier why doesnt the US get out that passport machines and make a passports for all its athletes saying there 16 thats all we need right is a passport nothing else matters right??
 
I don't think that because they aren't 16 they shouldn't compete. If there good enough why not? I knew one girl who was getting looked at for the american team along while ago before she was 16...but then she got an injury and well can't do gymnastics anymore but really if they have talent then let them in.

The only thing is there is a rule that states you must be 16 by December 31, 1992 to compete in the Beijing Olympics. Its really not fair to the other athletes who arent sneaking in underaged athletes.
 
I personally think that they are indeed too young.. I don't think they are emotionally ready for the Olympics. It must be a lot of Stress and i don't think it's right for a 14 year old.. :confused3
 
Well that doesn't make any sense.
They're saying that Alexandre Despatie (diver) won 4th place back in 2000, when he was just 15...

I guess the rules were different back then?

If that's the rules for this year, by friend should be in them come 2012 xP
She's a swimmer, she's intense.

Anyways, all I think is, if there are rules, they should be followed. If there weren't, then I'd say anyone who is ready to compete at such a large event, can..
But I can't say that.
 
China shouldn't be allowed to have under-aged team members.
It's a rule, and it should be followed by all countries, no exceptions
 
So what?!

If they're skilled enough and have enough training, let them compete!

Britain plans on sending a 14 year old to compete in diving.

At the Athens games in 2004 (or Sydney in 2000, I can't remember which), the US had a 15 year old swimmer. And we're sending another this year.
 
I think that if some other people that have competed for the olympics and they were too young to go to the olympics should aply to all the athletes.
I think it's sort of unfair for the other amazing gymnastic athletes that are too young to go to the olympics and when someone there age can go there but they can't is stupid.I love gymnastics too and i loveee watching it.
I think she should be replaced with a "legal olympian aged" athlete.
thats my opinion :)
i cannot wait to watch it on tv!!!P:
 
Wel I think that if China ends up being allowed to put underage olympians in the Olyimpics then they'd have to let other countries do the same thing.
But on another note, it might be harder for someone who is 14 to deal with the stress, pressure and responsibility that comes with representing you country in the Olympics.
 
So what?!

If they're skilled enough and have enough training, let them compete!

Britain plans on sending a 14 year old to compete in diving.

At the Athens games in 2004 (or Sydney in 2000, I can't remember which), the US had a 15 year old swimmer. And we're sending another this year.

The so what is America and Canada and possibly Russia have eligible girls who are not competiting due to there underage. Gymnastics rules are different than diving and swimming. Also I think Tom Daley should be aloud to compete because he is legally old enough in diving rules.
 
If they qualify in an event I don't care what age they are they should be able to compete.
 


Disney Vacation Planning. Free. Done for You.
Our Authorized Disney Vacation Planners are here to provide personalized, expert advice, answer every question, and uncover the best discounts. Let Dreams Unlimited Travel take care of all the details, so you can sit back, relax, and enjoy a stress-free vacation.
Start Your Disney Vacation
Disney EarMarked Producer






DIS Facebook DIS youtube DIS Instagram DIS Pinterest DIS Tiktok DIS Twitter

Add as a preferred source on Google

Back
Top Bottom