Chiminea Vs. Fire Pit/Bowl

[Pipkin]

My cast iron chiminea is nearly the end of its life. I use it on the patio, near the house. The walls of it are open on all sides, it sits up about 2 feet from the floor and has a chimney. The smoke goes up the chimney. Lately there is a big interest in fire bowls. I would also be using this on the patio, not down in the back yard. Both provide 360 seating if I want. Which is better? Is the smoke directed more away with the chiminea? Does it matter. Who has had both and which do you like?

 

[BillSears]

I've never owned either but I am interested in buying one soon. Right now I'm leaning towards the fire pit. I think I'll be able to put in a larger log and I also just like the look of this one.

Your question about the smoke has me thinking right now. Maybe the chiminea would be better?

 

[wiigirl]

I personally like Fire pits's better when they are set in the middle or are part of a table.

We have one that is natural gas and love it.

We have one almost exactly like this but with black stones. No smoke and no chimney to block people.

 

[SandrA9810]

The screen domes for fire pits seem to degrade quickly. I would find someplace to store it in the winter time, so it doesnt get ruined from the elements. Fire pits look cool, but chimneas are probably more functional for the long term.