We have never done Chef Mickeys but we did Garden Grill on our last trip. We LOVED it. Of course it is Family Style (all you care to eat, but brought to the table) as opposed to buffet style, therefore there aren't as many food choices, but I liked it because it seemed smaller and a little more intimate. It could very well be just because of the way the dining room is set up. Either way, we really loved it. And the character interaction was great. We saw all of the characters 2 or 3 times.