Thanks for all that replied to my e-mail. We ended up making the switch to CBR - though I can't say it went without problems.
Long story slightly shorter: we had to book our first night (Thursday 11/10) in a pirate room, as that was the only room available in the whole resort (not just with the discount - period). Still saved a bit of money over rack rate in a standard room.
Our second night (11/11) is another room only - standard room with PIN discount (25 % off)
The remaining 8 nights are
free dining, giving us an extra night of free dining. Hopefully we will not have to switch rooms yet again.
Overall we saved $221 versus what we were paying at POFQ (which was already a big savings vs rack rate thanks to free dining. (Total savings versus rack rates $1219.)
The one night in the pirate room hopefully won't be a big deal. We arrive late (flight lands at 7 PM) so won't even need to unpack our bags. I really am going to need to figure out how to get back to Custom House, as it looks like I'll have to do it at least twice.
DD8 looked at pictures last night and was very excited about the pool and playgrounds and beaches...but doesn't like the big skull and crossbones on the curtain in the pirate room. (She been waking up at night thinking her stuffed animals are vampires. I'd hate to think what a giant skull looks like in the middle of the night

Probably like a giant skull.)
Question: If we just push the curtain back for the night - is it pretty unoticeable that there is a skull on it? (Weirdest question ever asked on this thread?)