Cape May or Briergarten...which to keep?

[67mike]

Hi All:

I have to choose to keep one of these adr's:

Cape May or Briergarten for DINNER.

Which would you keep and why?

Thanks

 

[A_Princess'_Daddy]

Biergarten is my family's one absolute "must do" at WDW. We love the food & the friendly service, and the entertainment is our favorite of any WDW restaurant. From DS2 & DD5 to both my wife and I, we universally look forward to dinner at Biergarten.

Cape May is fine, in my opinion, but the seafood is nothing special and the atmosphere reminds me of a Marriott restaurant. It's not bad, by any stretch, but it is by no means distinctive or special.

 

[Disney_Cutie]

Personally I would keep CMC.
I have been underwhelmed many times by Briergarten the past few times have went and I don't typically like sitting with strangers..... just me though.

 

[MyTwoPrincesses]

LOVE Biergarten! The food is good - lots of variety. The beers are delicious. The entertainment is wonderful and if you have kids, they'll love the dance floor. It's a must do for my family.

 

[budbeerlady]

Biergarten is my family's one absolute "must do" at WDW. We love the food & the friendly service, and the entertainment is our favorite of any WDW restaurant. From DS2 & DD5 to both my wife and I, we universally look forward to dinner at Biergarten.

Cape May is fine, in my opinion, but the seafood is nothing special and the atmosphere reminds me of a Marriott restaurant. It's not bad, by any stretch, but it is by no means distinctive or special.

Biergarten was 100x better than our food at Cape May. Even sitting with strangers is alright if the food is great and there is entertainment. We were just not impressed with Cape May, it reminded us of Old Country Buffet. It was food, it was hot but not great.

 

[BriarRosie]

German food doesn't thrill me, and I think I got my money's worth from the snow crab legs on the Cape May buffet a couple months ago. The seafood isn't the best, but I still think it's decent. And there's enough variety for non-seafood eaters.

I'll eat at Biergarten if others want to go there, but it's not my first preference. And as others said, if the idea of being seated at a communal table with strangers skeeves you out, you're better off at Cape May.

 

[jess20k]

Biergarten!!!! We love it there. We did not enjoy Cape May though. Food was just ok.

 

[asdfghjkl13]

keep Biergarten. Although I've never eaten there, you can get seafood similar to CMC anywhere. (been to CMC, and the lines for the buffet were longer than any other buffet restaurant in WDW, and the food wasnt even that great.)

 

[Pakey]

Although neither of these places are near a "must do" for me, I do prefer Biergarten over Cape May.

 

[Karlzmom]

Biergarten, no contest!

 

[jacksmom]

We would keep Cape May! We enjoyed Biergarten, but hated eating with strangers!

 

[aenelson]

Biergarten!!!

 

[DONALD38]

We liked both places, this would be a toss up. This past trip we did Cape May over Beirgarten because this time crab legs are on the Buffet.

If you would like to stay in the park, choose Beirgarten. The food is good and you will probably sit with other guests. But the atmosphere is really nice inside with the live music.

If you choose Cape May it is only a small 5-10 minute walk from Epcot to the BC. You might have a better varaiety of food choices here. From seafood to ribs and carved meat.