We were at Cape May Cafe last Tuesday and really enjoyed our meal there. We were a party of 7 with seafood and non-seafood lovers. There was plenty of food for all of us. That night they had mussels, clams, crab legs, mahi mahi and a cold seafood dish of shrimp, pasta, dressing, etc... The non-seafood included a cut of beef, BBQ chicken and ribs, corn on the cob, mashed potatoes and of course the children's buffet and salad buffet.
I did not eat the seafood that night and I was fine. I am normally a seafood lover but by Tuesday we had eaten so much rich food that I could not face another meal of food dipped in butter!
The line to go to the buffet was always quite long on the evening we were there and the restaurant was very crowded but we did not feel crowded. Our server was competent but missing that little something extra. We had to ask for refills, etc... they just weren't brought to the table as they were the rest of the week. Nothing horrible just she was busy.
My DS(8) is GF and this was one of his favorite restaurants because he had so many choices and they provided GF rolls and flan for him. He had never had flan before and found out he loved it.
I do have pictures but as my home computer crashed the day we got home and I am using my work computer right now I can not load pictures yet but will hopefully later this week.
Hope this helps some!