Thanks for the replies!
That is too bad that they wouldn't rent it to you for the exact days that you wanted. I noticed on their availabiity calendar that there were spaces in between dates with 1-3 days in between. It seems like maybe that is happening alot and maybe they are losing money? I, too, can see both sides.
Tissa...thanks for replying again!!...I know you love this place...and I even told my DH about how much you raved about it! I felt very confident after you responded to me!! He wants to book it right now, but I keep trying to find more reviews...i can't find anything on Tripadvisor. I just don't want to get ripped off. My girlfriend is very skeptical of the internet and just cannot believe that I would book something online myself. She has me nervous after saying "what if you get there and there is no key. You find out that you were ripped off?? Then what??" Did you book with them after getting a recommendation?