debden said:
.....My sister has come up with a few evil ideas of her own. She said send him back the $50.00 check with a letter that says: Keep the $50.00 and buy yourself some honesty and integrity!.....
........
Oh, we're liking your sister!!!

You're right, though...it is too bad that this owner is acting like this...what a difference had he called/emailed you and said, *nicely*:
"Debbie, look, my management company just called and said there's a stain on the carpet. They think it may cost $100 or so to get it out.
I don't know where it is, and as I'm in the UK, I can't tell you myself, but I will find out and let you know. I'll return $50 of your security deposit, right now, and I'll let you know ASAP about the rest of it. I'll get them to take a picture of the mark on the floor. I'm sorry I can't be more thorough and clear about this right now, but rest assured, when I find out what's going on, I'll be in touch.
Thanks again for your booking, we're happy you chose our villa for your vacation..I know we'll be able to work this out."
Unfortunate that he made a different choice.
...(I would have sent the cheque back, just like you did...only with the added notation, "..Cheque unsigned and missing $100" !!!!!)
