Here's the Consumer Reports ratings if that will help (listed best to worst)
DIGITAL MODELS
Canon Elura 85 Elura 80
Hitachi Ultravision DZGX20A
Hitachi DZ-BX35A
Panasonic PV-GS300
Sony DCR-HC90
Panasonic VDR-D250,VDR-D300
Canon Optura 50
Hitachi UltraVision DZGX3200A
Sony DCR-HC26
Sony DCR-HC36
Sony DCR-HC96
Canon DC100
JVC Everio G Series GZ-MG505U
Sony DCR-DVD505
Sony DCR-SR100
Toshiba GSC-R60,GSC-R30
Hitachi UltraVision DZGX3100A
Sony DCR-DVD105
Sony DCR-TRV280 CR
Best Buy
Sony HDR-HC3
Hitachi Ultravision DZMV730A
Ultravision DZMV750A
JVC Compact Series GR-D270,Compact Series GR-D295
Sony DCR-DVD405
Sanyo Xacti C6
Panasonic PV-GS31
Sony DCR-HC46
Panasonic VDR-D200,VDR-D100
Sony DCR-DVD7
Canon Elura 100
Canon ZR700,ZR500,ZR600
JVC Everio G Series GZ-MG77
JVC GR-D650
JVC GR-D395,GR-D370,GR-D396
Panasonic PV-GS180
Panasonic PV-GS500
JVC GR-D350
Panasonic PV-GS39,PV-GS59
Sony DCR-DVD305,DCR-DVD205
Samsung DuoCam SC-D6550
Samsung SC-X210L,SC-X205L
Samsung SC-MM10S
JVC GZ-MG37U,GZ-MG27U
Samsung SC-D963
Sanyo Xacti HD1
Samsung SC-DC164
Samsung SC-D365,SC-D363
ANALOG MODELS
Sony CCD-TRV138