Hi there,
I'm new to these forums and have found this discussion interesting. We've been to CM for the the first time in Sept 2012 and then recently in on 20th Dec 13.
Having no previous experiences at CM to compare with (singing?? dancing?? buffet dessert?! TEN characters?!?!?!), we were pleasantly surprised.
First visit we met Mickey, Minnie, Pluto, Eeore, and Tigger. All ideal characters at DD was only 2 1/2, so great types for her to meet. She had loads of time with all the characters, and Eeore even came back for a second cuddle. We had the set meals - really enjoyed it, except for the service for our mains - they pretty much forgot to bring them to us (and asked if we were ready for dessert!!) but rectified it quite quickly. We sat upstairs, in the corner with a lovely view of the balloon. We were the first ones in. But overall, except for the service glitch, loved it.
So we weren't going to go this trip - had contemplated it for DD's birthday on the Tuesday of that week but decided to splash out on Auberge (not as many characters there as I would have hoped, but that's a different story....). As the week went on, we decided to make a last minute change to our planned restaurants and decided to book for CM on our last night (Friday). Booked for 6.15 and arrived just before. Again, we were the first people in the upstairs and got the same table!! What were the chances?!?! We met Mickey, Minnie, Tigger and Pluto (same as before!), but this time with Goofy. DD (now 4!) had met Mickey and Minnie earlier in the week, but was completely in love with Minnie so that was great. Hadn't seen Pluto or Tigger (so bouncing followed!!), and Goofy was just right for her age - he tickled her, pretended to mess about with the cash till/computer (which DD found hysterical and proceeded to tell on him to Minnie, Pluto and our waiter!!). Pluto and Minnie both came to us twice. Our waiter was lovely (sorry, don't remember his name) and was great with DD. We went for the set menu's again, and again enjoyed the food but I personally found the Cappuccino soup a bit cool. Service was great BUT I put it down to luck as we were the first table to arrive in that section. I did notice that when we were having our mains that some other tables hadn't yet had their starters, but they seemed to catch up.
We'll probably go back again when we go with my in-laws (their first Disney trip) in March, mainly because we know the food is good for DH's picky tastes, and as we could always do a slightly more budgetted option (shared pizzas) if we wanted to.
Hope that helps some people.....
C x