We have done the beach casabellas, upper veranda, and cabanas at the Menehune Bridge and the Ka Maka Landing area. We are obviously fans, but it is
definitely not something I would recommend to everyone.
Personally, I love the Upper Veranda for four people, but that won't work for your group unless only four intend to use it. It is off to the side, the view is amazing, and I liked the shade. They give you a call button so you can really set up camp for the whole day and have everything brought to you (same for cabana and executive lanai). My husband misses the tv when we do the upper veranda, but he does like the view better than the cabana. Also: We needed bug spray in the morning at the upper veranda. The bugs love us... (mosquitoes).
The cabanas at Menehune bridge are LOUD. Seriously. We also found people liked to sit on the lounge chairs when watching their kids splash around which was kind of weird. It didn't happen anywhere else, so we thought it was funny that it happened repeatedly just in this location. Not a big deal since we are a family of 3, but might lead to needing to ask people to vacate the chairs if you are a larger group (I hate confrontation, so that is the only reason I mention it).
We liked Ka Maka landing the best. It is quiet and the view is nice, but it isn't completely secluded. I liked that it was close to bathrooms, food service, and the pools. My husband liked the tv, my daughter likes the food plates that came in morning and afternoon (fruit in AM, dessert in PM). I liked having a frig and having a safe for our stuff.
We were next to a family with two young children one year and the cabana attendant brought them two packnplay to put in the cabana so the kids could nap in the shade. I thought that was genius! The kids slept and the parents all lounged around and ordered food/drinks. How lovely!
Anyway, we go to Aulani to relax. We barely used the pools our last trip and instead just lounged and went to the beach. We were there at Christmas, so it was really busy. For us, the reserved seating helps us achieve what we want... but I know there are plenty of people who would much rather grab some seats by the pool once in a while because they spend more time using the pools and doing other activities around the resort... for them, reserved seating is kind of a waste.
For what it is worth, I should also tell you about the beach casabella: Based on our constant use at the beach I tried the beach casabellas when my husband was feeling too tired to leave the room so it was just my daughter and I. Not a fan. It was ok. I didn't like all the sun. In the afternoon I was trying to hide inside the casabella from the sun (ugh). The wifi connection was very spotty. There is a different wifi for the beach area, which was better, but it still was unpredictable. If it had just been my husband and I and we liked the sun, then it would be a great spot. It just didn't work for us.
Nice thing about the casabella is that it is "relatively" inexpensive and you can reserve first-come-first-served in the morning.
I think the executive lanai would be amazing for a group. We never rented it because it would be overkill for three people, but it looks great. Nice easy access and amazing view.
For an even better cabana experience.... try Turtle Bay at the North Shore. AMAZING! We spent a day watching the waves and surfers on the most comfortable couch and amazing food. And... I think it was about $150 for the day. HA! A bargain!
