IMO, unlike many resorts, the location of every room at Boardwalk is a bit unique and has pros and cons. It's hard
to say that there are rooms that are universally considered "better."
I totally agree with this. If you have a pool/garden view, one of my favorite views is of the village green: its super close to the elevators, it's almost a boardwalk view, and because it's convenient to the elevators, it's easy to the boardwalk, shops, boat dock, etc.
ETA: there are relatively few BW villas that are truly “near elevators,” so be prepared to walk if you don’t get one. And if you end up on the far back wing near the tennis courts, if walking down stairs is at all possible, take the stairway at the end of the hall, and you’ll be halfway to DHS already. No boat needed, except on the journey home.
This is so true! We are out of strollers, at last, so last summer, we had one of the rooms facing the parking lot/tennis courts at the end. We used the elevators when checking in/out with luggage, but the rest of the time we used the stairs. It's the closest walk to the bus stop (won't matter for you, but was great when going to AK and MK), also a very short walk to both pools, and shortest walk in AC to DHS. It was a really noticeable difference. We are too impatient to take the boat, but as
@CarolynFH has said, if you catch it coming from DHS and get off at the Swolphin stop, you're a short walk on the boardwalk back to your resort. I think the family and I tested a few routes and if you walk on to the boat and it's *right there*, it is faster than walking. Otherwise, a moderate walk speed is faster. Walking is *definitely* faster than taking the boat all the way to the BW stop. Both are faster than the skyliner when staying at BWV, but it's a fun trip, so we've done that too.
In short: if you are in p/g view, "village green/near elevator" is the shortest walk to Epcot, and a fine walk to DHS. If you want to cut short the walk to DHS and don't mind a longer walk to Epcot, we liked the end of the hall by the tennis courts.
BWV is one of our favorite
DVC resorts, even though the layout and kitchen are not our favorite. (Much prefer the door to the second bedroom near the front door rather than in the living room.) We can't wait to stay there after the refurb; right now seems to be the plan to stay in every DVC at the latest possible time *before* refurb starts (going to BLT in late August, woot!)