For myself Kidani would win hands down because I love everything about AKL/AKV. That being said, it really depends on what you are looking for. I can take a bus from Kidani to AK in 5 minutes travel time, or wait 20 + minutes for a bus to pick me up at BWV to then take me to two other resorts before finally leaving for AK. I can take a bus from Kidani and arrive at MK in 20-25 minutes, or wait for 10 to 15 minutes at the BWV for a bus that will take me to 2 other resorts and then finally head to MK, taking an addl 15-20 minutes. Now if I am planning most of my meals at Epcot and want to spend time in World Showcase and at DHS, then Boardwalk is my #1 choice. If I want to get to all parks and not have transportation hassles, I better stay at AKL with dedicated bus service or an MK resort that includes monorail and boat transportation.