I know some will *flame* me on this,and I looked at this thread about 4>5 times, left it and came back before posting, but I would mention we all need to be 'responsible' on this, and understand that
DCL, is one of the few cruiselines to allow any booze on board.
Most cruise lines have a policy to confiscate any booze on embarkation, they say they do this for security reasons, and only give you the booze back on disembarkation, this is a truly awful process. Other cruiselines do this to force you to purchase their own drinks at the bars, at inflated prices and this brings in good income.
DCL also is very good in offering a wide selection of sodas for free at deck 9, and often you have to pay for soda on other cruiselines. My sister was just on
RCCL and spent a fortune on her kids for soft drinks, through her cruise.
So we should respect DCL for their, very open policy.
Most people like to bring small amounts of wine and booze to use in your own room and maybe at the pools. Yes DCL's wine is expensive, but no more than at a fine restaurant on land, and in thoose would you take in a glass of wine? Bring you own booze?
I like to have my wine on my verandah but, Personally I would not take any glass of drink into dinner, that wasn't purchased on board, or given out at the Captains reception.
The corkage fee is there for any bottle of wine, brought in and opened in the restaurant, by servers or yourself. Servers cannot tell if a glass of wine was purchased on board or poured in your own room from your own stock.
Now not wanting to cause a debate, but suggesting, please be responsible, and respect DCL's very favorable policy, as it could be withdrawn. There is another thread, why was REAS withdrawn, in part a reason is misuse, and maybe encouraged on these boards. Also CC club changes on booking times is another reason.
I have seen people bring in hip flasks in their jackets and pour out booze into soft drink mixers, when the servers are away, the servers see this, but as you 'tip' them at the end of the cruise it can place them in a difficult position.
(They bring up a charge, you reduce their tip).
Anyway just imho, PLEASE be professional and respectful, of DCL rules, they are very flexible, and if we take too much advantage, the fair policy could get withdrawn and we all suffer, we all have different opinions on what is OK, whats getting around the system or, bending the rules, or is the rules. I feel bringing in a glass of your own wine to dinner is bending the rules, but thats just mho.
Again, not wanting a flame/debate. but I feel we should have a balanced view on this, and have it put in 'context' Would we want DCL to ban all booze? If not, be sensible.